Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS
  • REVIEWS
  • INSPIRATION
  • COMMUNITY
  • COMPETITIONS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


Memory Card Readers

Memory Card Readers - The memory card reader is a useful device that connects to the computer's USB port, allowing images, music or video files to be uploaded from flash memory cards, without the need for the camera to be connected to the PC. In this buyer's guide Rebecca Bradley reviews nine of the latest readers on the market.

 Add Comment

Category : Accessories
Share :

 

SanDisk Imagemate

 

SanDisk Imagemate 12 in 1 card reader £29.99

Easy to use but not particularly compact. Has a docking station included with the product which seems a good idea at first glance, but when used, seemed to be too lightweight and was easily pushed over the weight of the cable. This however, can be easily removed. Reads 12 different types of card. Fairly expensive compared to a lot of other readers. Includes USB travel cable and Adobe Photoshop album 2.0 starter edition. May require installation of a device driver (included). Compatible with 19 different types of memory cards including xD.

Cable length: 100cm. Also has a handy travel 15cm cable.

Speed test: 4 seconds.

Verdictimg

 

 

Lexar USB 2.0 Multi-Card Reader
£24.99

Easy to use, and has an indicator light to show when card reader is connected, and when a card is being read. Also has a handy cover that clips on the front for use when the card reader is not being used.

Reads a variety of card formats, but is at the higher end of the price range. With a cord length of 83cm, I found it slightly too short.

Speed test: 8 seconds

Verdict: img

 

 

 

AFT Reader

Atech Flash Technology (AFT) PROGear Solo 10-in-1 card reader
£24.99

At the higher end of the price range is the AFT PROGear Solo reader. It is compact, easy to use, and is compatible with all the card formats. It has an indicator light to show when the card is being read and an ample cable length of 92cm.

Speed test: 9 seconds.

Verdict: img

Sandisk 3 in 1 Reader

SanDisk Extreme 3-in-1 card reader (USB 2.0)

£19.99

Lightweight and compact, the product is easy to use, but is limited in terms of the cards that can be used with it. Because of this it seems relatively expensive in relation to some of the other more versatile card readers on the market. While most of the others have four card slots, this one only has two, therefore may not be compatible with many types of card. See table below for exact compatibility.

Cable length: 94cm.

Spped test: 8 seconds.

Verdict: img

 

Lindy Reader

 

Lindy 23 in 1 card reader
£12.99

Great value for money and a lot smaller than some of the card readers available, but quite fiddly to use with the various card slots being on different sides of the reader. Having said this, it is compatible with all the different card types, and has a useful indicator light to signal when the card has been correctly inserted.

Cable length: 102cm.

Speed test: 11 seconds

Verdict: img

Hama USB 2.0 Card Reader
£11.99

At £11.99 the Hama Card Reader is good value for money, and is compatible with all
types of memory card, including the highly popular microSD card found in most mobile phones. It is compact, easy to use and has a useful indicator light to suggest when a card has been correctly insterted. At 50cm though, I felt the cable was slightly too short. Also when carrying out the speed test I discovered that there was a problem transferring the file, whereas all the other readers hadn't had a problem reading the exact same file.

Verdict: img

 

Kingston High Speed

 

Kingston Hi-Speed 15 in 1 Reader
£9.99

With 15 different varieties of cards compatible, this product is great value for money, although it is sometimes hard to tell whether the card has been correctly installed. Because of this, long term use may potentially cause damage to the pins of the memory card and render it unusable.

Cable length: 116cm.

Speed test: 8 seconds.

Verdict: img

 

 

My Memory USB 2.0 Card Reader
£9.99

Extremely compact and with a stylish design, the My Memory card reader has an indicator light to suggest when the card has been inserted properly.

Cable length: 72cm.

Speed test: 8 seconds.

Verdict: img

 

 

 

WINNER

Crucial Card Reader

Crucial Hi-Speed USB SD/MMC
12 in 1 Card Reader
£11.74

Fantastic value for money and easy to use,
the Crucial card reader is compact and
versatile, compatible with all types of cards.
A great all rounder.

Cable length: 94cm.

Speed test: 7 seconds.

Verdict:img

 

Speed Tests

The speed tests were carried out using a 100Mb file transferred from an SD card.

Product Compatibility

Which card reader you choose to buy obviously depends on how many different types of card you will be wanting to use with it, so here's a check list for you to see which reader is compatible for which types of card.

Card Reader Card Slots 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Speed

AFT 4 9
Hama 4 N/A
Crucial 4 7
Lexar Multi-Card Reader 4 8
Lindy 4 11
SanDisk Imagemate 4 4
Kingston 4 8
MyMemory 3 8
SanDisk Extreme 2 8


Availability:

All items featured in this article are available to buy from the following suppliers:

MyMemory
Sandisk
Hama
Kingston
Crucial
Lindy
Lexar
Picstop
Warehouse Express

Key to flash media formats

1 - Compact Flash™ (CF)
Includes CF I and CF II and CF Ultra Speed

Compact Flash Card

2 - MicroDrive® (MD)

Micro Drive

3 - Memory Stick® (MS)
Includes MS Pro, MS Duo MS Select, MS Rom and MS High Speed and MG (Magicgate)
Memory Stick

4 - Secure Digital™ (SD)
Includes SD High Capacity, and SD v1.1
SD Card

5. Multi Media Card™ (MMC)
Includes MMC Mobile, MMC High Speed, RS-MMC and RS-MMC High Speed.
MMC

6. Smart Media™ (SM)

Smart Media

7 - xD Picture Card™ (xD)

Includes Type M and Type H

XD card

Explore More

Join ePHOTOzine and remove these ads.

Comments


31 Dec 2007 2:00PM
Why no mention of Firewire Compact Flash Readers. My Lexar Media Firewire Compact Flashcard Reader is considerably faster than my USB 2 reader

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

IanA 10 3.0k 12 England
19 Apr 2008 10:23AM
The Lexar Firewire 800 reader is nearly twice as fast as USB 2, but it does need a Firewire 800 port (1394b). The standard Firewire 400 (1394a) is, in fact, a tad slower than USB 2 when that system is working at full capacity!

Ian Smile
ArnasJ 6 2
12 Sep 2008 1:21PM
Well, for me, speed is probably the most important characteristic for a card reader. SanDisk's speed is incredible, so for me it's still the winner! Another thing, some of the prices weren't the lowest you can find out there. Next time you do a test, check the prices at the link . That's the one I always I use, and prices are usually the lowest there. Regards

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.