Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS
  • REVIEWS
  • INSPIRATION
  • COMMUNITY
  • COMPETITIONS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


Help!? Which should I buy - CS4 or Lightroom 2?... or is this the wrong question


Handprint 6 4
6 Nov 2009 8:12PM
Help!... if it's out there - I am not interested in sophisticated image manipulation but more with old-fashioned D&Ptechniques (exposure, burning, dodging, removal of unwanted debris etc). Will Lightroom cut the mustard or do I have to cough-up for CS-4? I shoot in RAW and could be seduced by HDR capabilities. Many thanks, Andrew

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

miptog 9 3.5k 61 United Kingdom
6 Nov 2009 8:17PM
Lightroom should meet your needs
LeighRebecca 7 267 10 England
6 Nov 2009 8:22PM
I manage at the moment with DPP (the free raw converter for Canon) and elements 6. It can do those things you mention. And if you really want HDR, photomatix tends to be the tool of choice anyway.
User_Removed 10 17.9k 8 Norway
6 Nov 2009 8:30PM

Quote:Lightroom should meet your needs


Based on your criteria, I would agree.
miptog 9 3.5k 61 United Kingdom
6 Nov 2009 8:31PM
Agree with LeighRebecca's comments.

There is a FREE Beta of Lightroom 3.0 that you can download and trial just to see what the product can do, and thus make your own decision on what is best for your needs.
Kris_Dutson 12 8.2k 1 England
6 Nov 2009 8:51PM
Since I invested in Lightroom, CS doesn't get much of a look in.
Kapulco 7 10 8 United Kingdom
7 Nov 2009 1:24AM
Just like to put in a word for Serif Photo+.

An earlier version, reduced (SE) is available as a freebie:

http://www.freeserifsoftware.com/software/photoplus/

Or, for 10 one can choose the later V9.

I use the latest version - Serif PhotoPlusX3 Digital Studio (why, oh why, do software firms feel they have to change designations to keep abreast with Microsoft?) but that would cost 60. It allows the use of Photoshop plug-ins (as do many such programmes) but it is probably much more than you need - try the freebie first.

The latest (60) version:

http://www.serif.com/photoplus/

(NB the optional resource guide and the necessary P&P are extra).

I have used Serif for decades (literally). It is based in Nottingham, UK and produces excellent software - especially its flagship programmes (Page+, Draw+ and Photo+). And, no, I have no connections nor pay-back. C'mon Serif, I'm working hard here!

K.
User_Removed 11 455 13 United Kingdom
7 Nov 2009 9:38AM
I would support the idea of considering the Serif option. The level of functioning in the programs is often far more than you might expect for the price.

I used PhotoPlus 10 until recently but unfortunately had to give up on the versions following, including X3, because of the limited 16 bit handling - or at least the fact that saving in 16 bit removes all the exif data.

Strangely, although version 10 was not supposed to handle 16 bit it did, and better than the following versions, and it maintained the exif data.

The free versions are good, and they do keep to their 30 day money back if you buy and don't like it.

Take the time to try the trials of the various options.
Kapulco 7 10 8 United Kingdom
7 Nov 2009 10:04AM

Quote:I would support the idea of considering the Serif option. The level of functioning in the programs is often far more than you might expect for the price.

I used PhotoPlus 10 until recently but unfortunately had to give up on the versions following, including X3, because of the limited 16 bit handling - or at least the fact that saving in 16 bit removes all the exif data.

Strangely, although version 10 was not supposed to handle 16 bit it did, and better than the following versions, and it maintained the exif data.

The free versions are good, and they do keep to their 30 day money back if you buy and don't like it.

Take the time to try the trials of the various options.



Good points, thanks Brett,

As most of my work is neo-insane - well, takes images almost as far from the original as is possible - EXIF does not matter to me. It may well to most "straight" photographers; so do bear in mind Brett's point there.

I try to run on a commercial basis, therefore have to keep costs low where possible. If I need to pay more for a tool which is necessary, I will try to buy it but, if I can save money elsewhere, without compromising final image quality, then I do. Very successful commercial photographers and well-off enthuiasts do not have such limitations (or, at least, to such a degree) so will probably always opt for the latest Photoshop. But, hey, there is a 2,500 Canon available soon I'd like - or maybe... Smile

Thanks again, Brett, and good luck in your searches, Andrew.

K.
Handprint 6 4
8 Nov 2009 8:14PM
Many thanks to everyone for the excellent response and advice - much appreciated. Front Page News: Having taken pity on me a friend has given me a genuine boxed CS3 as they were given CS4 by their girl-friend - this should, from your collective advice, be more than enough! Who knows I might even start making my original photos look better... pah! good composition is for losers any way.

Once again, my thanks to you all.

Kind regards

Andrew
Jestertheclown 6 6.4k 241 England
8 Nov 2009 10:21PM
I know Andrew, that you're sorted now but to continue re. Serif for anyone else that may be interested; if you contact Serif and express an interest in one of their products, they will latch on to you like a leech.
That's a nuisance if you don't want their attention. in which case politely saying so does the trick but if you play your cards right they will sell you their suites at far lower prices than they are advertised at.
I've got PhotoPlus X3 and have just been offered, in a phone call from Serif, their most recent version (I can't remember the name) for 19.99.
The saleslady started at over 300.00 although, obviously, that's just to impress you and no-one would ever pay that (?).
Instead you just need to keep feigning an interest but saying you can't afford it and the price will fall.
Not only that but with every "I'll just speak to my supervisor" gap in the conversation, she kept adding additional "free" software.
I've had many similar calls and each time, had I been interested, I could have made a considerable saving.
Their stuff's pretty good too.
I've also got PagePlus X3 (what M$ Publisher ought to be like), DrawPlus X3 and ImpactPlus X3. All of which are excellent and I think I only paid about 30.00 for the lot.
Jester.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.