Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS
  • REVIEWS
  • INSPIRATION
  • COMMUNITY
  • COMPETITIONS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


Nikon D3200 or Canon EOS 550D ?


sluggyboy 2 1 United Kingdom
16 Nov 2012 8:33PM
hI,, I am off tomorrow to purchase my fist dslr , i have a budget !! been looking at both the D3200 and the EOS 550D Would very much like your thoughts ?

Many thanks

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

tpfkapm 4 166 United Kingdom
16 Nov 2012 8:40PM
Either
Get the one that feels best in your hands
sluggyboy 2 1 United Kingdom
16 Nov 2012 9:11PM
Not a majorly constructive reply , but thanks for your time ,,any more help guys ?
tpfkapm 4 166 United Kingdom
16 Nov 2012 9:45PM
it is the most honest of replies and given the question an entirely reasonable answer.
both can take fine pics so it will come down to how they feel in your hands and if you like the menu system

btw... i have a budget doesnt mean much unless you qualify it with a figure

sorry to not spend your money for youWink
16 Nov 2012 9:53PM
Sluggy, it is a good reply, albeit short. But it is the best answer.

Now for me, I would go for the Nikon out of the two as it feels more rugged and has the better grip to the Canon (I am not a fan of the Canon build and grip, but that is me)

However, you may find that the Canon is the better one to suit your needs.

Now that big question is what do you want to get out of the camera? Do you want to shoot family, holidays, be creative, shoot in a studio, shoot sports etc. There is a lot of genres out there. Most DSLR's these days are very close in performance and you choose which camera suits your needs for what you want. The big difference comes down to lenses. Do you want to have all the lenses you could ever want, or stick to a small range of focal lengths.
Also, the processing of the data from the camera can give differences to the shot, slightly warmer, slightly richer, more true to life, more contrast, less contrast etc etc. But that is the fun about photography Grin

May I make a suggestion that before you decide on the default selection, that you also give a consideration to the Pentax K30 and the Sony A37. Both are more left field than the usual suspects. Pentax for example is fully weather sealed, and partnered with a sealed lens, allows you to shoot in any weather with excellent results. The Sony has the pellacle mirror where it has an evf rather than an ovf, but can give you some speed. Both will provide you with the ability to use some old lenses which you can get on e-bay (nikon is the same to some extent, Canon won't take the pre EOS lenses)

I am afraid it is not just the case of which is the best camera, but more of a case of which is the best for me.
But I would strongly suggest that you really try all the alternatives withing the price range, rather than the two usuals, before you make a decision. You may be surprised that you come home with something other than a Canon or Nikon. But on the other hand you may choose one of the ones you initially selected, and for that you have made the best choice for you.

I hope this helps. Grin
Newdevonian 2 462 United Kingdom
17 Nov 2012 7:45AM

Quote:Not a majorly constructive reply , but thanks for your time ,,any more help guys ?


I note your masthead statement "Hi new to photography so any helpful hints / tips would be very gratefully received."

TPFKAPM's answer was the best advice anyone could give, so your answer was a little less than gracious. Perhaps "tips would be very gratefully received." could be put into practice?
kodachrome 3 535
17 Nov 2012 8:21AM
If its of any help, I use a Sony A37 and its the most user friendly DSLR [SLT] I have ever used, not to mention the fact that Konica Minolta AF legacy glass works on it as well.
The Pentax K30 was mentioned and I think that is another very user friendly camera.
The Nikon D3200 is a fabulous camera, if not a tad more noisy at high ISO so a couple of review sites reported. The Canon 550D is also a very good camera but my money is on the Sony or Pentax. This is just a personal preference. Read the reviews on the A37, It gets 5 stars from nearly every review site.
Steppenwolf 3 1.2k
17 Nov 2012 8:49AM
If I were buying a new system now I would be considering the latest CSCs - not DSLRs. Have a look at M4/3 - unless you've got a special reason for buying a DSLR.
Snapster 2 137 England
17 Nov 2012 11:15AM
Just read the thread, so I'm a day late.
Lets us know what you got and why.
gjfereday 2 46 United Kingdom
17 Nov 2012 1:38PM
Quote:- Canon won't take the pre EOS lenses!

What a load of poppy ****! I had exactly the same dilemma as yourself earlier this year & opted for the 550d! It's a fantastic camera & easy to use & it definitely uses the per EOS lenses, I use them regularly! In fact I'm using one now taking pics of my kids in the skate park!

I'm glad I chose Cannon & would recommend it as an excellent buy!
Sooty_1 4 1.4k 212 United Kingdom
17 Nov 2012 9:10PM
By pre-EOS, do you mean FD ones? Breechlock ones? In which case, you must be using an adapter, manual focussing and guessing the exposure?

Nick
22 Nov 2012 12:24PM

Quote:Get the one that feels best in your hands


I agree. The main difference between different entry level DSLRs is how they handle. To expand:

- Ask someone how to change the aperture, shutter and ISO in full manual mode. These are the three settings you're going to be constantly fiddling with you need to be able to change them all comfortably whilst looking through the viewfinder.

- See which one looks nicer to you, has better build quality etc.

- Look at all the brands, not just Canon and Nikon. The weather sealing on the Pentax K30, which Offertonhatter mentioned, is a much bigger advantage than marginally better performance at ISO 6,400, or whatever it is camera review sites are obsessing over these days.
Niknut Plus
5 918 64 United Kingdom
22 Nov 2012 3:26PM
I've tried both cameras.....& my test shots were rather disappointing from both cameras !!

Both suffer from 'noisy' images (grainy), from ISO 400 upwards, particularly in the darker/shadow areas !!

The Nikon results simply weren't sharp ??, but that could be down to the kit-lens ?

The Canon results were very sharp in comparison, but still 'noisy' ?

Result ?....I didn't buy either, the quality of the results simply weren't up to scratch !!!!!!

It might be a bit late ?......but hope that helps !!
pluckyfilly Plus
8 337 33 United Kingdom
25 Nov 2012 12:23PM
I am in the same boat (so to speak) I use a Nikon D300 and looking to upgrade - considering the 3200 or 5200 coming onto the market in December!

I have a very good friends using the Nikon D7000 and he is a very happy bunny, he had the D300 prior to his new toySmile
pluckyfilly Plus
8 337 33 United Kingdom
25 Nov 2012 12:26PM
Should have said be careful, I bought a NEX on recommendation and for me it did not feel I had a camera in my hand, obviously NOT for meSad

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.