Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS
  • REVIEWS
  • INSPIRATION
  • COMMUNITY
  • COMPETITIONS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


Paintshop or Photoshop


Mounters e2
8 84 2 England
24 Dec 2006 11:59AM
As recent convert to DSLR I am on a very steep learning curve. I have a copy of Paintshop which seems to do most things but the software of choice on EPZ appears to be Photoshop. Which way should I go?

Thanks for your help Merry Christmas and a snappy new year!

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

trivets12 e2
10 1.3k
24 Dec 2006 12:03PM
Hi Mounters,
Photoshop Elements 5 is now out and I think you will find it more than adequate for your needs. There is a tendency to think of Photoshop Elements as a watered down version of Photoshop which, I suppose it is, but if you look at www.photoshopelementsuser.com you will see that this programme is capable of amazing stuff!
Nip down to PC World or whatever, and buy it then you can play with it all over Christmas!
Have fun,
Trudy
strawman e2
11 22.0k 16 United Kingdom
24 Dec 2006 12:04PM
It's a lot like cameras. If you are using one and happy stick with it. everything has plus and minus.

I have Photoshop elements and use it with C1 LE and some power tools to do all I want. But plenty use the tool you mention. The only limitation I know of PSP is its colour management capabilities, oh and the fact it is not photoshop.

So if you are happy stick with it.
cambirder e2
11 7.2k England
24 Dec 2006 12:08PM
If you are happy the PSP does everything you want it to, stick with it. I have used it for many years, and prefer it to PSE.

If you want to compare them, then down load the 30 day trial, before you splash any cash.
samfurlong e2
8 2.5k United Kingdom
24 Dec 2006 1:48PM
As has been said, if you don't find that PDP is limiting you then stay with it.

However, there is a reason why photoshop is the industry standard image editing program. It's the best, pure and simple.

Personally, having used photoshop since version 3, I find PSP incredibly limiting and badly designed - can't stand it.
Someone gave me a free copy of ver 8 a while back, I installed it, used for about 3 mins then got rid of it again.


Photoshop can be hard to learn but there is an alternative - photoshop elements. It has most of the key features of full photoshop, is a bit easier to use and costs about a fifth of what photoshop does.
It's good if only to serve as a stepping stone to photoshop, get used to the basics of it and the interface before going on to photoshop later on.
pamelajean e2
8 831 1638 United Kingdom
24 Dec 2006 2:40PM
I have always been happy with PSP and, although I can see that many members use Photoshop, I haven't yet been tempted to change.
However, I anticipate developing more PSP skills next year, and may then find it limiting, but having not used Photoshop at all, I have nothing to compare it with.
24 Dec 2006 3:31PM
Its nice to see that Elements is starting to catch up with PSP. The straighten function is a nice new addition to Elements 5 but still not as good as PSP's. But its the same with all similar software, one is good for this and the other for that. I suppose its a bit like designer clothes, some just have to have "The Name" brand and use its name like a badge despite the fact that it's uncomfortable to wear and will loose its style in the wash. Myself, I have both on the go because neither is the full answer.
tepot 10 4.4k United Kingdom
24 Dec 2006 5:07PM

Quote:some just have to have "The Name" brand and use its name like a badge


Thats how some folk are with lenses, Some third party lenses are just as good as a "brand name" to all intents and purposes for example.
tepot 10 4.4k United Kingdom
24 Dec 2006 5:09PM
i use psp7 and elements 2, they provide me with all i need, i don't feel photoshop is worth all that cash just for mere amateurs like meself.

p.s oh and rawshooter of course.
nikon5700ite 10 1.8k
24 Dec 2006 8:11PM
The reason that PS is Industry standard is becuase it was first on the market and that doesn't make it the best by a long shot. It is handicapped by the format that it started with and I wouldn't be suprised if it dies away and Elements is developed up to replace it as a more freindly programme to work with ... the advantage that the newer programmes have over PS.
culturedcanvas e2
9 4.7k 59 United Kingdom
24 Dec 2006 8:15PM

Quote:The reason that PS is Industry standard is becuase it was first on the market and that doesn't make it the best by a long shot.


Nope .. it's industry standard because its simply better. However it is a lot more involved in terms of learning to use it effectively.

Dan
tepot 10 4.4k United Kingdom
24 Dec 2006 8:30PM
photoshop offers way more than most of us will ever need, save your get a cheaper package and spend the cash saved on a new chunk of glass.
keithh e2
11 23.4k 33 Wallis And Futuna
24 Dec 2006 8:34PM

Quote:It is handicapped by the format that it started with and I wouldn't be suprised if it dies away and Elements is developed up to replace it as a more freindly programme to work with ... the advantage that the newer programmes have over PS


Hey it's chrimbo and I'vbe drunk half a bottle of southern but that passage of text is the daftest thing I've read all year



oh...and PS wasn't the first and I've been using it since version 1 and I used three Beta's before that.
strawman e2
11 22.0k 16 United Kingdom
24 Dec 2006 8:37PM
By all means use PSP, but it is by no means the best. And its interface is not better it is just different. As a challenge let me know when you find the colour management feature.

It is an entry level package, just like Photoshop Elements.

Oh and the format has changed twice that I know of. So I am struggling with the handicap bit.
bricurtis e2
9 1.9k 48 England
24 Dec 2006 8:40PM
I have always alternated between PSP8 and Elements 2 depending on which function I found best to use from these.
I had Elements 5 as a present when it came out and I must say it is quite a comprehensive package and offers many functions.
From your original question I think your answer could possibly be Elements 5 for your needs.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.