Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS
  • REVIEWS
  • INSPIRATION
  • COMMUNITY
  • COMPETITIONS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


Request to publish my kids' work - then sell it back to them :(


newfocus e2
8 644 2 United Kingdom
17 Dec 2008 9:04PM
I just got a letter which originated from a third-party publishing company sent home from my kids' primary school. They said some pictures my kids had drawn had won a competition and would be published in a book (with our permission).

My kids were really hyped up over it but when I looked closer it seems the company regularly do this kind of competition and it looks to me like they simply publish books full of kids' pictures and charge 14 a go for copies, which the kids obviously want lots of for relatives, etc. because their work is in the book.

I'm handling it carefully but I object to my kids being subjected to this kind of emotional sales hook so young. They were offered no fee for the work and no free copies of the publication, which I'd imagine an adult would be offered at minimum.

I'd just be interested if anyone else has seen similar stuff going on at their school or otherwise.

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

mr g e2
10 403 3 United Kingdom
17 Dec 2008 9:42PM
This is a common technique used by publisher - it started off with poetry competitions " Your fabulous poem has won our competition and will be published!" - Oh, it will cost you 9 to buy the book.

We no longer take part in any of these schemes and the children themselves often see it as a 'rip off' and the fact they they haven't won at all, but have been taken advantage of.
Rob
Carabosse e2
11 39.7k 269 England
17 Dec 2008 10:06PM
Treat it as your kids' first lesson in life about rip offs! Wink
newfocus e2
8 644 2 United Kingdom
17 Dec 2008 10:13PM
Yep - that's what I figured. My oldest daughter was surprisingly grown up about it. She wants to see her picture in print but she can see that publishing it without giving her anything in return, then charging her money for copies of the book isn't 'fair'. All in all I think you're right - I should thank them for a valuable early lesson Smile
bill777 e2
11 164 1 United Kingdom
18 Dec 2008 9:11AM
Yes, it can be a problem. I had exactly the same trouble with pictures in a certain photographic book at ePhot.... whoops!! Wink

Bill
agoreira 11 6.0k Wales
18 Dec 2008 10:04AM

Quote:Yes, it can be a problem. I had exactly the same trouble with pictures in a certain photographic book at ePhot.... whoops!!

Bill



What? You mean the togs never got paid for their shots? Wink
Seriously though, I think some of these books/mags etc appeal to people's vanity, people will willingly pay to have their work featured. They can then say they are a "published" photographer! Wink They don't mention that not only didn't they get paid for their work, but they paid to have in included. Most seem happy to do that, and the publisher is even happier! On the subject of "published" photographers, we have a pro tog near us that advertises himself as "an award winning photographer", and when I looked to see whaat he had actually won, it was the first round of a competition of some sort. Him and hundreds of others, I imagine, but technically he had won an award, and I don't suppose many will ever check to see what award.
simont e2
10 2.2k 4 England
18 Dec 2008 11:38AM
I seem to recall Pete sending out similar e-mails when he was publishing "The Book"!


Smile
Sus e2
10 3.2k 9 England
18 Dec 2008 6:45PM
Someone I know has just received a similar letter, but for a poem. Entered by the school.

Do the schools get a cut in all of this? What benefit is it to them? Or do they not realise what it is?
Overread e2
6 3.9k 18 England
18 Dec 2008 6:56PM
Schools will either get a cut or - again - the the abilty to boast.
"Students work published"
which - at least if the school is private - is something that can only attract potential parents to the school
If its not that they might get some deal like a little off on their orders from the book company or some such. They might not benefit at all and just not see a downside to it for them (since its not them doing any of the selling or publishing - they don't lose out on anything)
newfocus e2
8 644 2 United Kingdom
20 Dec 2008 11:55AM
Sadly, the techniques of psychologically manipulating kids in order to sell to parents is are well understood in the marketing industry (Google "nag factor" or "pester power" if you want some evidence).

I'd have expected schools in this day and age to be well briefed on this kind of tactic and filter what gets passed on to the kids accordingly though (especially to year 1 kids) but maybe that's asking too much.
Carabosse e2
11 39.7k 269 England
20 Dec 2008 11:56AM

Quote:Sadly, the techniques of psychologically manipulating kids in order to sell to parents is are well understood in the marketing industry


Particularly noticeable at Christmas time! Wink
User_Removed 8 2.1k 7 England
20 Dec 2008 12:30PM
My daughter had a poem published via the school but we got free copies of the book, about 5 I think. Then we could buy more if we wanted. Her's was in the summer too.
newfocus e2
8 644 2 United Kingdom
20 Dec 2008 1:13PM
That sounds far more reasonable. I did ask if in this case the kids could have just a single free copy each but the publisher refused.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.