Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS
  • REVIEWS
  • INSPIRATION
  • COMMUNITY
  • COMPETITIONS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


PRIZES GALORE! Enter The ePHOTOzine Exclusive Christmas Prize Draw; Over £10,000 Worth of Prizes! Plus A Gift For Everybody On Christmas Day!

what is the difference between full blown photoshop and elements?


scartlane 4 68 United Kingdom
22 Feb 2012 1:20PM
Other than the price,
Theres a pretty good deal on at pcworld on ADOBE Photoshop Elements 10, Im messing about with trail version and bowwing my mates computer to edit some pics, i was thinkign of investing, but reading the blurb im struggling to see what the differences are,

does anyone have or know where i can find a difinitive list, prehaps its my lack of knowledge or tiredness i just cant get my head around it

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

andart 12 491 United Kingdom
22 Feb 2012 1:43PM
this article might help, though it also includes lightroom in the mix..........................................
scartlane 4 68 United Kingdom
22 Feb 2012 2:01PM
that did help, most of the stuff i dont really recognise,
I guess the main things im asking are does it support the actions like in CS4 /CS5 (as ive done my own that i want to keep using) and does it support layers.
from what i gather it seems to just wondering if anyone has any working knowlege
MrDennis 5 247 Wales
22 Feb 2012 2:23PM
Amazon have a Good price on the 10..Check it out.
mikehit e2
5 7.1k 11 United Kingdom
22 Feb 2012 2:43PM
Elements 10 supports layers and layer masks (introduced in v9).
Several of the functions in Elements are very good but not quite as good as PS (for example, Content Aware Fill).
You can import actions from PS to PSE, and although PSE does not have a command to create actions in PSE there is a workaround (goole 'PSE actions').
You can't soft-proof in PSE.

Overall, the main difference in functionality is the PSE is intended as a photo editing programme whereas PS is an all-singing all-dancing graphics and desktop publishing package.
Dave_Canon 8 940 United Kingdom
22 Feb 2012 5:50PM
I have Photoshop CS4 Ex, Lightroom 3 and Elements 10 but it would take a lot of time to list the differences many of which may be of little interest to you. I have Elements only for training purposes but use LR and PS CS4 myself. There are a number of features on PS that I would not wish to be without. I am sure that Elements 10 will meet the requirements of most amateur photographers but I want all the features and with a scientific background I am quite happy with the compexity. As I only use Raw files, over 80% of my editing uses Lightroom so Photoshop is becoming less important. You may be able to Google comparison reviews.

If you are fairly new to image editing, you will probably not outgrow Elements 10 for at least two years anyway so it is probably worth starting with Elements anyway.

Dave
lawbert 7 1.8k 15 England
22 Feb 2012 6:06PM

Quote: with a scientific background I am quite happy with the compexity.



What is a compexity? Is it a tool from adobe im missing out on?Tongue
BigRick 9 2.1k 3 United Kingdom
22 Feb 2012 9:52PM

Quote:I have Photoshop CS4 Ex, Lightroom 3 and Elements 10 but it would take a lot of time to list the differences many of which may be of little interest to you. I have Elements only for training purposes but use LR and PS CS4 myself. There are a number of features on PS that I would not wish to be without. I am sure that Elements 10 will meet the requirements of most amateur photographers but I want all the features and with a scientific background I am quite happy with the compexity. As I only use Raw files, over 80% of my editing uses Lightroom so Photoshop is becoming less important. You may be able to Google comparison reviews.

If you are fairly new to image editing, you will probably not outgrow Elements 10 for at least two years anyway so it is probably worth starting with Elements anyway.

Dave



I use elements 9 after using CS2 and 4 and 5.... i couldnt see the point in spending 700 on the full version, when i could spend 70 (now 34.99) on elements. I dont miss any tools, except the actions, but as already said there is a work around for that.

I have been using elements for a couple of years, and wont be changing any time soon, and yes, i do use my version for paid work, and i am certainly not new to editing pictures, but elements does me fine.

Its all about what you want to do with the program that will determaine what version is right for you or not.... if you are a full time graphic designer or photo editor etc, then the full version would be for you, whereas if you are a full time photographer, that does some editing on their photos, then i rekon elements is the way to go.

Download the trial of each and see if the tools on elements are too few, or the full tool list on CS5 is too great, and theres your answer. Smile
Miles Herbert 12 1.8k 4 United Kingdom
22 Feb 2012 11:30PM
For those with Elements it's also worth having a look at Elements + which unlocks several odds and ends hidden in Elements ... such as "Curves" (the free demo will unlock curves).

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.