Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS
  • REVIEWS
  • INSPIRATION
  • COMMUNITY
  • COMPETITIONS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


Worries about my online digital images being stolen.


TimJ e2
11 482 2 United Kingdom
31 Jan 2005 1:25PM
I would like to know whether or not any of you worry about your online digital images being copied or the idea of a photo copied.

It is actually part of my dissertation about digital copyright and it would be great to get some of your opinions. If you could take a few seconds to fill in a quick survey it would be really appreciated, just follow the link below. You'd be really helping me.

Digital Copyright Survey

Thank you,

Tim.

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

Carabosse e2
11 39.7k 269 England
31 Jan 2005 1:27PM
I'm not at all worried - but I'd be worried about having my email address as my handle. What an invitation to spammers/scammers. Wink
sillyconguru 10 4.4k
31 Jan 2005 1:31PM
Very true, CB.

I'm also not that worried, the images are too small (and probably not good enough) to be really useful to anyone.
TimJ e2
11 482 2 United Kingdom
31 Jan 2005 1:31PM
Handy if anyone wants to get hold of me though and spam filters work a treat! Smile
TimJ e2
11 482 2 United Kingdom
31 Jan 2005 1:32PM
Hi Andrew,

Don't forget though that someone can still pinch the idea of one of your photos and recreate it. That's still copyright theft. Wouldn't you be annoyed if someone made money out of your idea for a photograph?
sillyconguru 10 4.4k
31 Jan 2005 1:36PM

Quote:Don't forget though that someone can still pinch the idea of one of your photos and recreate it. That's still copyright theft. Wouldn't you be annoyed if someone made money out of your idea for a photograph?


Eh? Oh look, I've captured an image of a tree. Oh no, someone else has stolen my idea and has taken a photograph of another tree. ??????

I get your gist, but it doesn't worry me. They'd probably do a better job. Jeez, I've seen images in the past and "copied" (or tried to) the photographer. The resulting images are still mine (I took them). How else are we to learn? Hasn't every photographer "copied" another's style in the hope to improve?
31 Jan 2005 1:46PM
there is no such thing as copyright on a good idea.
TimJ e2
11 482 2 United Kingdom
31 Jan 2005 1:53PM

Quote:But copying, per se, however much skill or labour may be devoted to the process, cannot make an original workLord Oliver (cited Interlogo v Tyco [1988] CPR 343)


If it could be proved in court that you had knowingly copied another photographer's photograph then you would own no copyright in that image and therefore would have no right to sell it. However I would suggest that proving such a thing would be almost impossible.
Carabosse e2
11 39.7k 269 England
31 Jan 2005 1:53PM

Quote:Don't forget though that someone can still pinch the idea of one of your photos and recreate it. That's still copyright theft.


No it isn't. Useful site on copyright law here
sillyconguru 10 4.4k
31 Jan 2005 1:57PM
Re-creating a scene/image isn't the same a copying an actual photograph. I'd assume that there is no law against inspiration?
TimJ e2
11 482 2 United Kingdom
31 Jan 2005 1:57PM
Sorry, I take your point, technically not copyright theft. However, a copied artistic works (photo) cannot qualify for originality and would not be protected under the Act.
TimJ e2
11 482 2 United Kingdom
31 Jan 2005 2:02PM
Recent legislation regarding digital copyright has come under heavy critism for "limiting creativity". You have touched upon one of the points that I draw upon in my dissertation; what is to stop two people having the same idea?

Of course there should not be a law against inspiration, so are emerging international laws unsuitable?
snapbandit e2
10 2.2k 3 Northern Ireland
31 Jan 2005 2:06PM

Quote:what is to stop two people having the same idea?



Or two, say sports, photographers standing together capturing the same action, from similar viewpoints?

Joe B
sillyconguru 10 4.4k
31 Jan 2005 2:08PM
They might have the same idea, but the final products/images would (more than likely) be different. Apple & Micro$oft had the same idea (to use Xerox's WIMP system as part of their Operating Systems, except that Micro$oft basically stole Apple's idea).
elikag e2
10 749
31 Jan 2005 2:10PM
I don't know about "being inspired" being aginst the copy right law or not (think not), but one thing you could do is to reduce the ppi of the images you upload to mere 72ppi (and "save for web" feature of PS CS does that automatically). That way, printing your photos would be almost imposible (at any acceptable quality).

Ilia Kagan.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.