I think the light in this is quite beautifully rendered, however the tightness of the composition at the top, distracts from the overall effectiveness of the shot for me... Dave

I like the underlying idea here Eric (excuse the pun!), but the hands need a little more contrast or maybe a dash of find edges to put them 'into' the rocks more convincingly I think. Just a suggestion you understand... Dave

The colours in the planking are lovely Sarah, I might have gone for two shots here to improve the foreground sharpness overal. Still works very well though... Dave

It's a fine shot Dave and benefits from the square crop. I find that Photomatix can over-do the greens a bit sometimes and maybe a selective colour layer with the black turned slightly down would help a little... Dave

I like the work you've done with this and it generally works very well, apart from the shadow of the lamp on the wall, which really shouldn't be there when the lamp is lit. Small niggle on an otherwise good piece... Dave

I like the detail in this one Roger, the woods is great as is the window and floor detail. I wonder whether the processing hasn't evened the tones out to a point where it's become a little flattened. Maybe if the shot were slightly darker it would help. After saying all that, it's still a fine shot.