PaulHolloway

Like the sky but the icy loch doesn't have enough interest for me for such a large part of the image. I would have got closer to the hole and made more of it and the reflections in it or zoomed in on it if it was too dodgy to get closer.

Lovely light showing off the rich autumn colours and good reflections. Compositionly feels a bit onesided with the hillside and its reflection on the right being the dominant element. The reeds on the the left hand side are IMO not strong enough to provide the balance. So maybe recompose more to the left and look for a stronger foreground element. As far as I remember there's a solitary tree here which makes a great foreground for an image.

I like the composition but for me its a pity about the greenish clouds around the bright sky. Without that I think it would have been a very good image