Pentax SMC 50-200mm f/4-5.6 DA ED Interchangeable Lens Review

This telephoto zoom lens from Pentax competes in an area that has become popular as a first ‘extra’ lens since the introduction of cropped sensors. Designed for use on the *ist D series of cropped sensor cameras, we take a look at how it performs.

Specifications

• Focal length 50-200mm
• Construction 11/10 elements/groups
• Max aperture f/4-5.6
• Min aperture f/22-32
• Angle of view 31.5-8.1º
• Filter size 52mm
• Min focus 1100mm
• Dimensions 63x83mm (approx)
• Weight 0.261kg
• Mount Pentax KAF
• Price (SRP) £209.99

Build and handling
Pentax have a deserved reputation for small, lightweight equipment and this offering fits the mould well. The lens is a neat, relatively compact offering that will have little effect on the shoulder muscles when added to your camera bag. The construction, although by no means bomb proof, is good enough for most purposes and the feel of the zoom and focus rings was smooth and torqued at just the right level.

The majority of the barrel is taken up with a heavily ribbed zoom ring which, when turned clockwise from the 50mm mark, extends the lens by some 40mm by the time it reaches the 200mm mark. Forward of this is a rather narrow manual focus ring which has markings in both metres and feet and extends the front of the lens another 15mm by the time it reaches it’s closest distance of 1.1 metres, a handy distance for a 200mm lens. It did seem, however, that the MF ring is only there as an afterthought that rotates during autofocus.

The autofocus was relatively quiet although nowhere near silent and was quick enough for many subjects although it did struggle with flight shots and would do the same with fast cars etc.

The lens is finished off with a supplied, conical hood that is a firm bayonet click fit. The non-rotating front element takes a 52mm filter, which is a common size and not too expensive.

Optical quality
For the price, this lens performed quite well. There is a small amount of distortion throughout the lens’s focal range and it is pincushion all the way. However, it is not serious, with figures of 0.4% at the wide end going to 1.7% at the longest length. The nice thing about the lens is the consistency across the frame from centre to edge throughout the aperture range and focal lengths. The lens is as good at the long end as it is at the wide end, something that is highly commendable.

Contrast is good, probably due to the consistency of the lens, however, the one letdown is the control of CA. Although not in the realms of ‘horrible’ there are occasions when the phenomenon does rear its ugly head. Fortunately though, it is not to the extent that it cannot be overcome in software applications when it does.

Although the lens does not reach a peak until around f/11, you will see from the accompanying charts that the rise from wide open is not that great, making the lens usable from the off.

This lens covers all of the popular portrait lengths. Close framed portrait of a Peregrine Falcon taken at 1/180sec at f/8 and 180mm on ISO 200. On board flash and aperture-priority.	The focal length range of this lens allows for some creative framing. 1/500sec f/8 50mm ISO200.
Despite the high contrast in this shot, CA did not show to the naked eye. 1/750 f/8 138mm ISO 200.	Again here, the shot was framed to include the reflection.1/500sec, f/8, 68mm at ISO 200.

Click on each comparision photo below to view full size versions

50-200mm set at 50mm and f/8	50-200mm set at 200mm and f/8
50-200mm set at 50mm and f/4	50-200mm set at 200mm and f/5.6

Below is our lens test data. To find out how to use these graphs look at this article: How we test lenses

DxOMark provides objective, independent, RAW-based image quality performance data for lenses and digital cameras to help you select the best equipment to meet your photographic needs. Visit the DxOMark website for tests performed on the Pentax SMC 50-200mm f/4-5.6 DA ED.

Summary
Despite its small size and low weight, this lens performs more than adequately. The focal range is ideal as a second lens on the cropped sensors of the cameras that it is designed for. (*istDxx range) Autofocus is perhaps a little dated and often has a last tiny jerk to acquire its final lock but is accurate once it is there. Pentax have done well to achieve such pleasing performance in such a small package for what is a very reasonable price.

In summary, the positive points of the Pentax SMC 50-200mm f/4-5.6 DA ED lens are:
Lightweight and compact
Consistent optical quality throughout range
Good value for money

The negative points are:
Chromatic aberrations under some conditions
Autofocus a little frustrating at times
Manual focus ring small and rotates during AF

Check the latest price of the Pentax SMC 50-200mm f/4-5.6 DA ED here

Test by Ian Andrews