Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here

G15 or G1X

JeffreyW 11 1 United Kingdom
26 Mar 2013 10:43AM
I am considering a new camera.
Which should I go for, the G15 or GX1, both by Canon.
I want excellent image quality.

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

ikett 7 545 England
26 Mar 2013 11:27AM
Good review of the G15 here .
ChrisV Plus
11 2.1k 26 United Kingdom
26 Mar 2013 11:53AM
G1x [the GX1 is a Panasonic m4/3 camera - also very good] will completely blow the G15 away for IQ - especially at higher ISOs. The sensor is much larger meaning not only much better performance at higher sensitivities, but greater colour depth too.

The G15 does have a faster lens and a slightly longer zoom range. I don't know how important those things are to you, but the gains from aperture and longer equivalent AoV will not allow you anything like the same control on depth of field, make up for the poorer sensitivity or give you much more effective reach as the greater resolution of the G1x means you could crop to make up some of the difference and get more detail anyway.

There's a side by side comparison here .
cuffit Plus
11 319 5 England
26 Mar 2013 12:08PM
I bought the G15 recently; my G5 was showing its age but still pretty good; however, it was never a camera you could put in your pocket. I saw both Canons at the recent NEC show and primarily went to look at the Fuji range which, are all the rage - and Pansonics don't disappoint either if you are casting your net wider at some point. I hope to travel a fair bit to some European capitals and London (I am resident in UK) and the main criteria was that it had to fit into a pocket. I have noticed the increase in pickpocketing in cities, in fact it is almost visible in some and I am not sure that, despite best efforts of the police, that they can deal with it all. I also have SLR kit so didn't want to buy into extra lenses for a compact and I decided on the day that I didn't want to spend the same money on a compact as an SLR despite the excellence of the kit on show.

I understand that the G1X is better in low light and certain other areas, but wi-fi or GPS is not important to me and the G1X is the size of my G5 and not quite as comfortable in the hand, so I would handle both if you can before you buy. The absence of the LCD rotateable viewing is a negative on occasion but, to be honest, the trade off of a thinner camera is a better advantage on this occasion to me and the pictures I want to take. The pictures from the G15 are excellent in my view and pin sharp with the lens giving good blurring when you want it. The viewfinder is not as good as competitors (by a long way in some respects) but when I have used it the general pictures are equally as good so I don't see it as a problem, but I don't intend to use it for macro or anything really detailed. where the rear LCD would not suffice.

One thing that does niggle is that you no longer get a handbook and I find them useful when getting used to the camera (not that I wouldn't buy it because of that). If you area Canon owner already then the menus will be familiar to you on both but I have found it difficult to remember the different settings but practice will sort that out and I have printed the pages I need so I don't have to mess about with the laptop everytime I want to learn something new, rather than quickly flick to a page of a pocket book - it seems to be the way that things are going.

I received a Canon cashback for mine and I have seen the G15 at about 300 (UK company) rather than the more common price of 399 less 30 cashback - the cashback should apply to the 300 so it would be a really good buy for that price. My wife has the Panasonic T30 and my daughter the T20-something and they are both excellent compacts as well.

I hope this is helpful and if I can find the company selling for 300 I will send you a link - or PM me and I will reply in a day or so as I am away for a few days.

joshwa Plus
7 846 United Kingdom
26 Mar 2013 4:55PM
Carabosse 15 41.1k 270 England
26 Mar 2013 5:09PM
Looks like the G15 shades it overall..... 4.5 stars compared with 4 for the G1X.
ChrisV Plus
11 2.1k 26 United Kingdom
26 Mar 2013 7:44PM

Quote:Looks like the G15 shades it overall..... 4.5 stars compared with 4 for the G1X.

Josh may confirm this, but I imagine the scoring is relative to the class of camera and doesn't represent a 'better' camera, in absolute terms (if there is any such thing). There's always a necessary subjective element anyway - what's 'best' for one person may not suit another at all.

The OP mentioned image quality and I wouldn't imagine the G15 could compete in most tests.
iancrowson Plus
8 211 146 United Kingdom
26 Mar 2013 8:32PM
I had a Canon G1X and my wife has had a Canon G12 for two or three years. i bought the G1X as I thought it would be better the the G!2 which in some ways it is. I was disappointed with the G1x especially the dynamic range, it seemed to burn highlights too easily. I did have some good A4 sized prints, the lens seemed fine. I know you'r thinking of a G15 not G12 but I've always felt it was a cracking camera with outstanding results, varie screen and view finder.
I replaced the G1X with a Fuji XE-1 which is just excellent, better results than all the mid range DSLR's and so easy to control. Needs a big pocket!
Paul Morgan 17 19.1k 6 England
26 Mar 2013 8:57PM

Quote:I want excellent image quality

Its all about getting the right balance, what else is high on the list apart from image quality.

Pretty much any high end compact can easily manage printing up to A4 or A3 these days.
cuffit Plus
11 319 5 England
3 Apr 2013 11:58AM
Jeffrey, having asked the questions were the answers any use to you? Chris
JeffreyW 11 1 United Kingdom
5 Apr 2013 10:57PM
The answers were helpful, I think I may go for the G1X, BUT MAY WAIT TO SEE IF A MARK 2 is released
Paul Morgan 17 19.1k 6 England
6 Apr 2013 2:19AM
Are you wearing blinkers Smile

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.