Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here

Enter ePHOTOzine's Prize Draw, with fab gifts for everyone! Click Here

Whats the Best and Worst Lens Ever

3 May 2008 12:31PM
Best Minolta AF 50 mm @ f 1.4 worse Minolta AF 100-200mm but what for my Minolta Maxxum 7000 as I now use the Pentax digital system I like the optics it came with.

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

c_evans99 13 7.0k 1 Wales
3 May 2008 2:33PM

Quote:OMG, yes I'd forgotten Sirius and Hanimex lol

Worst I've used was the Halinar on my Halina 3000. Absolutely dreadful, no resolution, shocking barrel distortion, but I still had prints enlarged to 10 x 8 from it. At 15 I was easily impressed Smile

'Best' for me would be the Agfa Solinar - frighteningly sharp, punchy and excellent colour rendition.
Carabosse Plus
13 40.4k 269 England
3 May 2008 2:50PM
On SLR-type cameras:

Worst: Tamron 28-80mm f3.5-5.6 (fortunately only borrowed!)

Best: Canon 50mm f1.4 in both FD and EF variants, closely followed by Canon 17-40L.
riprap007 12 1.6k 37 England
3 May 2008 2:51PM
cheap and sharp 50mm Minolta
medium and useless a vivitar zoom (can't remember the focal length)
pro and good (underated) Nikkor 80-200 F2.8
jmolligo 10 60 United States
3 May 2008 7:52PM
I think the best lens made today is the Schneider 110mm Super Symmar XL (large format).
The best smaller format lenses I think would be the Leica 35/2 Summicron or 50/1.4 Summilux(35mm and digital). That's in terms of sharpness.
In terms of best overall - I think it would be the one you keep on your camera the most.
The worst - I don't know - I had a Toyo zoom once for 35mm that had noticably poor results and was ridiculously heavy (good for street photography, because it would make a good self defense weapon).
randomrubble 12 3.0k 12 United Kingdom
30 Jun 2009 5:08PM

Quote:The Praktica 50mm f2.8 Domiplan was classed as the worst lens ever tested by one UK photographic mag.

Ressurecting this because I just got a domiplan to try on my Eos bodies and was wondering if anyone has given one (or any other dodgy old M42 lenses) a go, if so any thoughts?
ade_mcfade 12 15.2k 216 England
30 Jun 2009 5:29PM
I've not used them all yet, so can't really say....
f8 13 9.2k 22 England
30 Jun 2009 6:02PM
The worst one was the quart size,made by Express Dairy marketed by Minolta.
Paul Morgan 15 18.4k 6 England
30 Jun 2009 8:10PM
The 42mm G Zuiko F1.7 attached to my Olympus 35 SP.

Just got a roll of transparencies back and I`m gob smacked with the lens, fantastic.
thewilliam 8 5.9k
1 Jul 2009 10:17PM
We used to have a scarecrow competition in our village, so one year I made a photographer. His "camera" was a small cardboard box covered in gaffer tape with a 50mm Domiplan lens stuck on the front. Real classy kit and probably the best use for this lens!
Freefall 13 675 United Kingdom
2 Jul 2009 9:35AM
Best I've ever used is the EF 50mm 1.4 - sheer bliss to use it. Not sure I've used a lens bad enough to call it the "worst" - even the Siggy 75-300 had its merits.
Fairclough 7 174
2 Jul 2009 11:26AM
Mmmm, fascinating. Lot's of love for fast 50s. Can't knock that. The Sig 50 1.4 is on my shopping list and I LOVED the EF50 1.8.

Best lens ever, the EF 50 1.8. The 1.4s are superior, but nothing gets close to the VfM of the little 1.8. A 70 lens that gives sharper shots than 1k L zooms. Costs bugger all, weighs bugger all, performs like a little superhero. Power to the people!

Worst lens I've ever had... Canon EF 75-300 MkII. I had a Cosina PoS in the same focal range back when I shot manual Pentax, and while it was rubbish, it was cheap rubbish. The EF 75-300 is a branded Canon lens. Basically, you expected the cheapest Daewoo to have compromises, but even the cheapest BMW should have been just a little bit special. And the EF 75-300 just wasn't. So everyone bought the superior Siggy for less.
boony 10 978 3 United Kingdom
2 Jul 2009 7:14PM
worse for me canon 38-76 kit lens i got with an eos 500. awful thing , was like shootiung through frosted glass. best for was siggie 10-20 not for sharpness or anyhting but was the first wide angle zoom i`d ever owned superb flexibility
screwdriver 10 35 United Kingdom
3 Jul 2009 12:57AM
Worse I ever used was a Tamron 17 - 200mm, really dire, I never got one image I could use out of it.

Best cheap lens, definately the Sigma 70 - 300mm Macro, bought off eBay for 36.00 inc P&P. The water boarder pic in my portfolio was taken with it.

jimthistle73 12 2.4k 1 United Kingdom
3 Jul 2009 1:28AM
Boony - is your new profile pic a gents' toilet?

Worst lens I ever bought was my first ever zoom, purchased by accident from ebay. Woke up after a night of heavy, ahem, socialising and found I was the proud owner of a 28-80mm (I think) Vivitar zoom.

Absolutely toss. Every photo I ever took was horribly out of focus.

Best lens? Would have to be my 17-55mm f2.8 Nikon. Sorry for being conventional....

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.