Back
Views 159 Unique 67
Vote 44
Award Shortlist   

castle menzies

By stephanfowles
took these shots on a day out to castle menzies, near aberfeldy, my first atempt at combining images so would apreciate critique, good or bad, thanks
stephan

Tags: General Architecture Landscape and travel

Voters: dawnmichelle, matmonty, gary_d and 41 more

Readers' Choice Awards are given to photos that get over 30 votes

Uploaded:
31 Aug 2008 12:50AM
More EXIF

Save 50% on inPixio Photo Studio Pro

Comments


dawnmichelle 13 12 United States
31 Aug 2008 1:26AM
wonderful way to display the images into one..well done
gary_d 13 576 13 Wales
31 Aug 2008 2:07AM
looks good to me. - gary
Ray42 12 3 England
31 Aug 2008 8:18AM
I think this montage works quite well
RobinF 14 83 1 England
31 Aug 2008 8:54AM
Very nicely done...never tried this, so I'll have to have a go!
regards,
Robin
pascalg Plus
13 37 1 France
31 Aug 2008 10:41AM
interesting montage ;
looks like a great place...

back to work tomorrow ; will mostly c&r for a couple of weeks, sorry
JONTHELENS 13 34 United Kingdom
31 Aug 2008 11:02AM
nice images and well presented.
sunshot 16 24 United Kingdom
31 Aug 2008 11:36AM
i'v never tried this but this looks great
well done
marc
lifesnapper Plus
14 8 3 England
31 Aug 2008 12:24PM
Very nicely presented. Lovely compilation.

John Smile
thorn 16 124 2 Scotland
31 Aug 2008 1:01PM
Beautiful architecture,detail,montaged images,lighting and presentation.take care,AnnSmile
jondee 12 United Kingdom
31 Aug 2008 1:02PM
magic, well done.
Mikelane 13 1 Wales
31 Aug 2008 1:06PM
Looks good to me well captured regards
Mike
foggytwo 17 36 1 Scotland
31 Aug 2008 3:21PM
It`s an unusual montage Stephan and it works very well.
Pete.
Jat_Riski 12 89 United Kingdom
31 Aug 2008 6:45PM
Excellent shot/s Stephan, well captured.
Preet
fatmod 14 22 England
31 Aug 2008 7:13PM
great images,well presented
whiteswan01 12 13 England
31 Aug 2008 8:24PM
nice montage
HobbitDave Plus
12 5 4 England
31 Aug 2008 9:12PM
Like it very much. Looks like a high-quality postcard! HDave :o)
Frase 13 Scotland
31 Aug 2008 10:06PM
Superb montage.
Don
SteveNZ 12 4 5 United Kingdom
31 Aug 2008 10:20PM
Hi Stephan - nice combination of images. Seeing as you've requested critique... the shot on the right seems a little overexposed to me - maybe this was to bring out the detail inside the doorway? I'd be tempted to play with dodge/burn techniques which could keep the interior detail whilst darkening the exterior (and matching the shades/tones of the other shots). Or am I just being a bit too pedantic?! Otherwise, looks great.
Cheers -- Steve.
nickyv32 Plus
13 135 England
1 Sep 2008 6:05AM
Great Montage, great collection.

Nicky
Rock 18 10 2 England
1 Sep 2008 8:21AM
Fine work .

With verticals the correct level must be kept so as not to distract the eye.

Rock
piccy 14 8 Wales
1 Sep 2008 11:43AM
A nice first attempt.
Freda
panda 16 5 1 England
1 Sep 2008 12:13PM
Nice montage, I think I would swap the two outside shots, so that the doorway is on the left, leading into the picture.

Regards Phil
SPARROWHALL 12 26 England
1 Sep 2008 1:00PM
Glad to make this RD. Really nice. Looks like a postcard.

Tracey
Tomaz 12 4 United Kingdom
1 Sep 2008 5:54PM
Love the way you have done this -
stephanfowles 12 United Kingdom
1 Sep 2008 5:58PM
thank you all for your comments,

hellion, will try and follow your advise

panda, that is a good idea will see how it looks

thanks

steph
Roly 13 Wales
1 Sep 2008 9:36PM
Looks good.It works well.

Roly.
hellsbells8868 12 151 2 Wales
2 Sep 2008 9:12AM
Great montage, i think it is fab....
MRSbiscuit60 12 224 United Kingdom
2 Sep 2008 12:57PM
Great work, but I might have tried it with a thin boarder round each castle as at first glance I thought it was one castle with alot of shade on one side, but thats just me. Great first try Stephan and thanks for all your votes on my PF. Trish
Last modified by MRSbiscuit60 on 2 Sep 2008 12:58PM
davidhu 15 19 United Kingdom
2 Sep 2008 5:20PM
Good result. I think I'd go with Trish and suggest a thin white keyline round the indivdual shots. Also I'd adjust the left and right images so they are the same size. Keep a look out for the photo mags, they quite often have image grids that you can use.
Dave
Last modified by davidhu on 2 Sep 2008 5:22PM

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.

Cookies help us deliver our service. By using our service, you agree to our use of cookies. OK Learn more