Views: 262 (95 Unique) 
Vote 72
Award Shortlist   

Culzean Castle

By RonnieAG
This view of Culzean Castle, Ayrshire, was taken in June, and I played around in Photoshop to give it an antique sort of appearance with an olive green vignette. I'm not sure how this will be received! But please feel free to be TOTALLY HONEST!
V 2 is the original.
V 3 has been added later and has white vignette as suggested by "Montana5".
V 4 has been added following Douggie's ("Scottishlandscapes") suggestion. I'm not sure if this is any better.

This was one of many shots taken on midsummer's day, many of which I have already posted under the "Culzean Castle Vol 1, 2 and 3" headings.

Details: ISO 200, 1/400 sec. at f/13.0, aperture priority.

Many thanks to all who voted for and commented on "Yellow Scabious" - your interest is greatly appreciated.


Tags: Architecture Ayrshire Digitally manipulated Culzean castle Landscape and travel

Voters: GERRYGENTRY, cantona43, morpheus1955 and 69 more

Readers' Choice Awards are given to photos that get over 30 votes

Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


cantona43 Plus
11 924 4 England
8 Jul 2010 12:12AM
a superb shot Ronnie but I like V1 the treatment you have done is outstanding

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

morpheus1955 9 3 2 United Kingdom
8 Jul 2010 12:14AM
Good morning Ronnie, what a fabulous image, I love the processing and presentation of V1, quite beautiful.

User_Removed 12 386 2 United Kingdom
8 Jul 2010 12:14AM
Excellent composition & presentation.
V1 for me.
andylea 8 37 1 United Kingdom
8 Jul 2010 12:23AM
good morning ronnie
cracking work here works for me a treat v1 for me today Wink
mikbee 9 3 8 Scotland
8 Jul 2010 12:25AM
It works well with the ageing process here Ronnie.It looks like the old pics they sell in the second hand shops here and charge the tourists oodles of cash for !!
gary_d 8 576 13 Wales
8 Jul 2010 12:58AM
I like the pov in the colour version and also the effect in V1 which fits the image perfectly. - gary
Daisymaye Plus
8 23 10 Canada
8 Jul 2010 2:04AM
Very good composition and pov. I really like both versions. Maybe V1, it seems to suit the image. But V2 is lovely too..........Sandy
taggart Plus
12 47 13 United States
8 Jul 2010 2:06AM
This isa beautiful image, love how you have finished it!
JimV 10 6 3 Canada
8 Jul 2010 2:23AM
Like this unusual view of Culzean Castle Ronnie, especially like what you've done in PS, somehow I have the feeling you had this in mind when taking the really well!
Rgds., Jim
Montana5 6 57 3 Scotland
8 Jul 2010 2:37AM
Ronnie, if I'm being honest and that's what you asked for, I feel V1 is spoiled by the vignetting process which has turned the Sepia effect green. Had the vignette been allowed to fade to white, in my opinion I believe it would have worked a treat, I realise the problem area was the trees in the bottom right of the picture and cropping them out would have spoilt the good composition.
Still gets my vote, because I often visit Culzean and I like the viewpoint you have used.
metro074 6 8 Australia
8 Jul 2010 3:49AM
A wonderful image Ronnie. V2 for me. Its splendid
CarolG Plus
9 196 18 Greece
8 Jul 2010 5:59AM
An excellent presentation in V.1, Ronnie, works very well for me. Carol
8 Jul 2010 6:57AM
Oh aye, we're commin'!
Beautiful shot, from a not so common angle - well done Ronnie,
VIKI 10 18 1 United Kingdom
8 Jul 2010 7:02AM
V1 is brilliant!!!!!!!!!
pluckyfilly Plus
10 351 33 United Kingdom
8 Jul 2010 7:47AM
love it, I realise what another member is saying about the greeny effect at the bottom of the picture but I much prefer V1 to the V2 or 3 although they are all good in their own way
7 10 10 England
8 Jul 2010 8:36AM
Three lovely images Ronnie all processed extremely well. V1 is tops.
luckybry 6 3 Scotland
8 Jul 2010 8:58AM
no 1 excellent but all 3 are very good
Alan_Coles 10 177 11 Wales
8 Jul 2010 9:30AM
Good variation and I like the colour v2 best.
johncob 6 18 United Kingdom
8 Jul 2010 10:01AM
Ronnie I like V1 -- it creates that timeless image. John
8 Jul 2010 10:16AM
Goor Morning Ronnie yet another miserable day in bonny Glasgow sigh....for me I like your modifications to the original especially V1 ...the effect you have achieved is more than a vignette it has added an ageing effect due to the colour and i feel it is very very well suited to the image and is in keeping with the main subject matter nice to see you experimenting it can be very rewarding keep up the good work click click click

For me Ronnie it's just the colour that is wrong. Sepia is the old style, always was, the green is just wrong for me. If you look at the old images you'll see how it was done way back. Great idea though and keep up the experiments.

RonnieAG Plus
6 153 116 Scotland
8 Jul 2010 10:19AM
Thanks to all for the comments and Dougie, I shall have another go with a different colour for the vignette.
Montana5 6 57 3 Scotland
8 Jul 2010 10:45AM
Ronnie thanks for adding a v3, I think that looks better, it certainly gives it more of a sepia effect, without the green cast, I also think it would look good printed.
edit...v4 just added but still prefer v3.
Thanks for taking the time to look at my idea, it does work for me at least.

Looks very realistic, now you have to give the edges that well thumbed look... LOL only joking my friend.

Ray42 8 3 England
8 Jul 2010 10:59AM
A good shot and some good work - believe it or not I like V4
8 Jul 2010 11:11AM
Yes V1 and V4 work for me, its all a matter of taste and for me any departure from what is norm is well worth looking at hope your having fun with all these mods Ronnie

Quote: Looks very realistic, now you have to give the edges that well thumbed look... LOL only joking my friend.


is this V5 on the way ??????
RonnieAG Plus
6 153 116 Scotland
8 Jul 2010 11:15AM
Thanks for coming back, Douglas, to review V 3, and thanks also to you, Dougie, for your comment re. V4. I am most appreciative of your taking the time to do so, and for your suggestions which were most welcome.
Thank you also, Graham, for taking another peek and for your further comment.
8 Jul 2010 11:31AM
great shot! V1 is perfect.
8 Jul 2010 11:40AM
its all good stuff Ronnie click
TrevBatWCC Plus
8 12 10 England
8 Jul 2010 11:53AM
Good morning Ronnie. Like the effects you've achieved here, think V1 & V4 are my faves, prefer the toning in V4.
TrevB Smile
8 Jul 2010 12:48PM
Great set Ronnie love v1 the Effect on it is ecellent love it.
8 Jul 2010 1:13PM
Hi Ronnie, for me has to be between V1 & V4.
V4 wins due to sepia toning of vignette.
Great image.

8 Jul 2010 1:22PM
Beautiful capture and the effects on V1 is perfect
V3 for me, it reminds me of the old postcards.
8 Jul 2010 3:52PM
What a superb set of images, Ronnie, like all versions, superb processing.
8 Jul 2010 4:23PM
Hi Ronnie. Great work, V4 for me. Great set & Very good composition.
Regards Evgenya
Lillian Plus
7 22 17 United Kingdom
8 Jul 2010 4:37PM
A well presented set Ronnie, like V1 and V3 for the sepia look
great shots
EAS 7 1 13 Scotland
8 Jul 2010 4:54PM
Enjoyed viewing all 4 of these lovely variations. Have to say, despite reading the above comments, rather like V1 with V3 being a very close run second for me.

8 Jul 2010 5:57PM
Hi Ronnie, excellent images. My fav. has got to be V1 followed by V4.

That green vignette works for me. Looking at the above comments I believe it is a case of "horses for courses". The art of photography is subjective. Isn't that what photography is all about?

If an image simulates discussion then as far as I am concerned that image is an excellent piece of art, time to get off my soap box, LoL Smile
Nice work.
PaulLiley 7 2 13 United Kingdom
8 Jul 2010 6:12PM
Hi Ronnie, Like 3 and 4 the best. The sepia colours are very creative. The subject matter lends itself very well to this treatment. Like it! Paul
Roly 9 Wales
8 Jul 2010 8:05PM
Its a good shot Ronnie.I like all versions,especially V4.
Anjantoo 8 7 1 England
8 Jul 2010 10:24PM
I really like V1, it carries the theme really well.
dmhuynh72 8 44 3 United Kingdom
8 Jul 2010 11:18PM
I think v4 worked best for me Ronnie. Very nicely captured image.

8 Jul 2010 11:33PM
Great work and presentation Ronnie. Well done. Cheers Gordon.
Shane136 13 63 United Kingdom
9 Jul 2010 9:17AM
What a great set of images

teocali Plus
8 441 18 England
9 Jul 2010 9:42AM
Excellent set Ronnie - definitely V1 as this really works for me. Lovely light and processing.
mrjt 10 United Kingdom
9 Jul 2010 3:23PM
Each in its own right..........Jack.
Brilane 10 5 12 Wales
9 Jul 2010 6:32PM
nickyv32 9 135 England
11 Jul 2010 3:10PM
Great shot, No 4 would make a smashing Postcard

18 Jul 2010 2:16AM
Great Shot. Love it.
User_Removed 8 26 2 United States
6 Aug 2010 1:37AM
I love the sepia coloring - very stunning.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.