Views 256 Unique 104
Vote 73
Award Shortlist   
Amazon Kindle Unlimited Offer: 6 months at 50%


9 Aug 2010 2:38PM
Super shots. Prefer V1.
CarolG 14 199 20 Greece
9 Aug 2010 2:43PM
V.1 for me, Johanna, a lovely composition, well captured. Carol
mishu78 11 Canada
9 Aug 2010 2:44PM
Great shots. V1 for me too.
Cormy 13 3 England
9 Aug 2010 2:53PM
I guess that place on the hill is Mikbee's country seat.
jaktis 16 84 Sweden
9 Aug 2010 2:53PM
Great with the flying birds

9 Aug 2010 2:58PM
Great shots, I prefer V1 with the birds.
TrevBatWCC Plus
12 13 16 England
9 Aug 2010 3:09PM
Not actually visited this part of Edinburgh, but looks a nice peaceful area, Johanna. Two delightful images - if I had to choose a favourite, V1 I think.
TrevB Smile
EAS 11 1 13 Scotland
9 Aug 2010 3:13PM
Been there many a time and always enjoy watching the Swans and ducks on the water. V1 with the flying birds for me!

Rock 18 10 2 England
9 Aug 2010 3:29PM
Grand work Lass.

mikbee 13 3 8 Scotland
9 Aug 2010 3:49PM
Cormy is not far away with his comment Johanna.As kids we used to climb the ruins of St Anthony's chapel as you see in the BG here,and then swim is this water which is called St Margarets Loch !! Nowadays I have no engery for that,but I might go back one day and feed the ducks !!
Good shots.
lonely_oryx 13 61 55 England
9 Aug 2010 4:03PM
I prefer #1 with all the birds flying around
debu 10 India
9 Aug 2010 4:15PM
Lovely set of images.
luckybry 11 3 Scotland
9 Aug 2010 4:19PM
no 1 is fantastic
robway 15 318 Wales
9 Aug 2010 4:47PM
Great scene and I love all the action with the birds. Superb capture.

MickyMc 13 8 United Kingdom
9 Aug 2010 4:48PM
Great , I have not seen it from this angle
andylea 12 37 1 United Kingdom
9 Aug 2010 5:01PM
two wonderful captures cracking colour and detail v1 for me today brilliant timing nice one Wink
Herge88 Plus
13 40 6 England
9 Aug 2010 5:08PM
Two nice captures Johanna.

Best Matt
GillyB Plus
15 317 8 United Kingdom
9 Aug 2010 5:14PM
Hard choice between the 2 Johanna, for me V1 has better colour but V2 works well without the distracting figure on the left edge .....

gill Smile
Maiwand 13 3 73 England
9 Aug 2010 6:54PM
Two great shots Johanna but I think my choice is for V1 with all the gull activity.
pluckyfilly 14 351 33 United Kingdom
9 Aug 2010 7:11PM
maybe just maybe you should have cropped out the person you can just see on the left more noticeable when viewed large but otherwise a great shot, very tranquil
danbrann 16 640 17
9 Aug 2010 7:16PM
Two good images Johanna and good reminders for you. If you toggle between versions 1 and two it is like being on the water in a boat.
Mavis 18 143 2 England
9 Aug 2010 7:18PM
This is a fine composition Johanna . What were you feeding them on ? xx
Dave_Holdham 11 4 1 Wales
9 Aug 2010 7:29PM
Two wonderful images
Roly 13 Wales
9 Aug 2010 8:43PM
Super image Johanna.V1 for me.
two great pics, V1 was my Fav.!
goso 14 2 1 Australia
9 Aug 2010 9:46PM
Good work Johanna - caught well...Bill
taggart Plus
16 47 14 United States
9 Aug 2010 10:53PM
Love bothe of these images, Johanna-- Special reminders of your trip!
teocali Plus
12 442 18 England
9 Aug 2010 11:08PM
Lovely clarity and comp Johanna - V1 for me .
photophantom 12 108 3 Philippines
10 Aug 2010 12:51AM
gorgeous shots and composition Johanna
Daisymaye Plus
12 23 18 Canada
10 Aug 2010 2:39AM
Two fabulous shots Johanna, both wonderful but V1 is my favorite..........Sandy
bunbeam 15 2 United Kingdom
10 Aug 2010 11:55AM
amazing, love all the birds
franfoto 13 2 32 England
10 Aug 2010 1:27PM
I'm set to enjoy your series on Scotland Johanna, I always imagine Edinburgh as being all built up but your shots show it has pretty views too. I like the remains of the chapel in the background and the activity of the gulls as in #1.
sparklep 13 146 1
10 Aug 2010 10:47PM
Great capture.
JimV 14 6 3 Canada
11 Aug 2010 5:26AM
Don't believe I've ever been there Johanna, so thanks for showing, when I looked at the thumbnail and read the caption I thought Johanna has gone bonkers Smile
Rgds., Jim
metro074 10 8 Australia
11 Aug 2010 6:29AM
Superb images. A wonderful peace of heaven potrade very well
11 Aug 2010 9:54AM
Oche Aye most impressive
Ray42 12 3 England
11 Aug 2010 12:04PM
Two lovely shots giving the flavour of Scotland - v1 is my choice but the horizon is listing to starboard slightly
Jekaro 11 1 United Kingdom
11 Aug 2010 1:21PM
Two fabulous images, Johanna, V1 for me if only for the gulls in-flight.
Porthos 10 80 1 Northern Ireland
11 Aug 2010 3:27PM
Great shots. V1 for me.....Derek
11 Aug 2010 5:49PM
Great shot of the Lochhere Johanna usually their are lots of swans here, one of them chased my sister and Mother many many years ago.

AnneWorner 13 620 43 United States
11 Aug 2010 10:18PM
Large is always better, especially when there is so much detail to see. Love the flurry of movement in the front of the frame.
FeatherFriend 12 38 217 England
11 Aug 2010 11:04PM

Quote:Two great shots Johanna but I think my choice is for V1 with all the gull activity.

My thoughts too Jo, both lovely shots though,
porty2003 17 97 Scotland
12 Aug 2010 9:44AM
Lived just down the road at Portobello for 9 years and never once went there !.Ah well....Smile
V1 hits the spot for me,the birds add a sense of 'Joi de whatever the phrase is' for me !! WinkSmile
mrjt 14 United Kingdom
12 Aug 2010 2:47PM
A first class Landscape set, with plenty to look at....Jack
Caledonia 14 2 Scotland
13 Aug 2010 7:17AM
V1 for me. Oh! it's lovely to see the birds in flight on such a beautiful landscape. I like the light on the hillside which picks out the trees. Excellent in large format!
Glostopcat 14 255 2 England
13 Aug 2010 9:42PM
Two excellent lakeside scenes, I'd never have guessed these were taken in Edinburgh. I bet local Ediburgh resident Mikbee wishes he could attract this many birds when he visits the park! lol
gerrymac 13 10 1 United Kingdom
29 Aug 2010 8:44PM
Really like this one Jo lovely scene and a wee bit of action from the birds

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.