Views 489 Unique 259
Vote 106
Award Shortlist   

Comments


CarolG 14 199 20 Greece
16 Aug 2010 1:46PM
Colour for me, Kathy, but only by a whisker. Carol
GarethRobinson 14 1.0k 2 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 1:54PM
Stunning images both are really well done.
Gareth
justin c 16 5.1k 36 England
16 Aug 2010 1:56PM
Both are very nice but the black and white version is my favourite of the two.

Justin
16 Aug 2010 2:02PM
Great image - I like both versions !

Chris
mrswoolybill Plus
14 2.4k 2290 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 2:21PM
I wasn't expecting to prefer b&w but I do, it seems to convey depth and distance better. But that streak of mist in the distance is magical in colour.
Moira
Mynett 12 142 6 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 2:25PM
love them both too hard to choose.... Smile

Linda
Cormy 13 3 England
16 Aug 2010 2:26PM
Both superb.
Cheers
Alan
Moj_o 12 10 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 2:47PM
Great image. I like both too! Smile

Betty
Craig99999 11 19 1 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 3:09PM
great processing cathy, struggling to choose between the versions, both excellent work.

Craig
IanFlindt 16 740 21 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 3:17PM
Colour version for me, Kathy. Flipping gorgeous.
SurreyHillsMan 13 27 2 England
16 Aug 2010 4:23PM
Mono for me... fab!

Jon
RonnieAG Plus
11 154 119 Scotland
16 Aug 2010 5:07PM
A so nicely composed image and captured in excellent detail despite the soft back lighting The scene has such a peaceful and gentle atmosphere to it. I cannot decide between the colour and mono versions, so 1/2 vote for each.
Ronnie.
TONKSPHOTO 10 2 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 5:20PM
Loverly natural shot.You want to walk into it..JT
Richsr 13 91 223 England
16 Aug 2010 5:31PM
Like the details and your composition Kathy, Have to go with the mono image as the sky and details seem to stand out better in this.
Good capture and conversion.
Regards Richard
pmorgan 14 217 13 England
16 Aug 2010 5:32PM
Both excellent - there's your RC!

Rgds
Paul
Richsr 13 91 223 England
16 Aug 2010 5:43PM
Congrats on the EC Kathy.
Regards Richard
DaveMead 11 23 14 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 5:45PM
Well done on the EC Kathy, well deserved for an excellent image. I don't mind which either. Smile
Dave
cassiecat 12 39 46 England
16 Aug 2010 6:09PM
love them both. great processing. congrats on the EC.lesley
SlowSong Plus
12 9.3k 30 England
16 Aug 2010 6:29PM
Beautiful quality of light and colour. V1 for me.
Chris
sut68 17 2.0k 77 England
16 Aug 2010 7:45PM
Fabulous and easily deserving of the EC [and more besides].

V1 first, then V2 ... I think Grin

Paul
Gaz_H 14 150 1 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 7:54PM
Very Moooooving.... lovely image Kathy. Congrats on the well deserved EC.
User_Removed 10 10 1 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 8:03PM
Colour Smile
chris-p Plus
15 72 England
16 Aug 2010 8:22PM
Simply brilliant...
Hebe 13 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 8:32PM
Absolutely wonderful.
JouŠo 16 56 Finland
16 Aug 2010 8:33PM
Colors for me!

Congrats on the EC!

Jouko
michaelcombe 11 46 2 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 9:31PM
V1 for me, great atmospheric shot!

Michael
neonknight 16 1 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 9:42PM
Both excellent nice work,John
cabbie Plus
13 31 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 9:47PM
V1 super work well done

Bob
paulcr Plus
16 1.5k 9 Ireland
17 Aug 2010 9:04AM
The processing on these is brilliant. Also a great "moment" caught. Paul
IanFlindt 16 740 21 United Kingdom
17 Aug 2010 9:13AM
Many congratulations on all your awards, Kathy.
KathyW 17 1.8k 12 Norfolk Island
17 Aug 2010 10:49AM
Thank you all for your comments, votes & awards Smile Smile Smile
ade_mcfade 16 15.2k 216 England
17 Aug 2010 12:29PM
colour I think
chase Plus
15 1.9k 481 England
17 Aug 2010 6:26PM
Colour for me Kathy,well done.
Nigel_95 Plus
14 262 2 United Kingdom
17 Aug 2010 10:17PM
Both are positively 3D Kathy. I slightly prefer the colour version, except for the sky which appears to have more depth in the mono version.

Nigel
rontear Plus
17 23 9 England
20 Aug 2010 9:43PM
Has to be colour ! Kathy. Ron.
DaveU 14 1.4k 125 England
20 Aug 2010 10:35PM
Something about the mono just does'nt look "right" to me .... the colour version is far more subtle and dare I say moo-tastic.
stevenb Plus
17 279 7 England
23 Aug 2010 12:19AM
V2 for me

Bill

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.