Views: 91 (51 Unique) 
Vote 13
Award Shortlist   

Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


achieverswales 7 8 101 Wales
20 Jun 2011 7:13PM
Excellent composition and good whites, but no blacks only gray tones.



Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

Georden 6 11 England
20 Jun 2011 8:14PM
Thanks for the comments Trev, I really appreciate your time. This is probably very basic, but is the lack of blacks a problem with the photo or the way I have processed it? I used a B&W layer in Photoshop & moved the sliders until I saw what I thought looked OK...
achieverswales 7 8 101 Wales
20 Jun 2011 10:17PM
Hi There
You have processed the correct way by not just desaturating the image, sometimes in the B/W window Auto does a good job, but I also play with the sliders to get the best blacks, if this is the best you can get then it has to be, I thought playing with the greens should have given better results.


Georden 6 11 England
21 Jun 2011 7:02PM
Trev, thanks for explaining this. I'll give it another go ASAP. I guess I need to learn to spot real black & white tones!
SecRATary 7 1 Wales
7 Jul 2011 8:26AM

Hmmm ... strange that the others above cannot see 'black' in your image. I get 'some' blacks, but having said that, I've just done my monthly recalibration of my monitor.

Great image ... I like it, especially the sky.

I like the bird too, did you wait until it flew near the 'rule of thirds' or did you crop to it ? Wink

Well done ...

Cheers ...

Dave (R.A.T.S.)
Georden 6 11 England
10 Jul 2011 5:11PM
That is interesting Dave. Thanks for letting me know. As for the bird, I wish I was that good, a crop I'm afraid...
sawsengee Plus
11 6 15 Malaysia
20 Jul 2011 6:39PM
great shot with excellent picture tone & for composition, I would stick to the rules of thirds but zoom out to capture more sky and more cloud reflection in the water.....just a friendly opinion.....regardsSmile
jackson8472 9 11 1 United Kingdom
30 Jul 2011 1:41PM
Hi George.
Not a bad mono, however, for me there's too much going on with the trees & clouds. Don't get me wrong, the clouds are great & the bird, but I would've got the shot from the other end (towards the sports centre) across the other angle (you know where I mean) there is a small clump of trees that side too. Then I would've used the 'rule of thirds' better from that angle. Hope you know where I mean? This is positive criticism mind, not negative....Also, with this angle, try putting a bit desaturated colour back into the trees, not too much, just that little hint.
Email me the image & i'll try it out & return.
25 Sep 2011 8:10AM
Good as it is george

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.