Back Modifications (15)
Views: 79 (33 Unique)  Award Shortlist   


By xwang
I tried a few photos this morning.I was amused to see the pigeon on the sign."Lost?I thought...unlikely for the pigeon, more likely for meSmile.I thought that it might make a good silhouette,but I wonder if it qualified as one.I'm not sure about the composition either, I cropped it from landscape frame.Also I'd like to know anything technically wrong with the photo.I didn't do anything on the photo, apart from reduced hightlight to -3, and increased shadow+1.I don't know what I should do really.Settings:F6.4;S1/1328;Focal length35mm;ISO200.All commments and criticism are very welcom.Thank you.

Tags: General

Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here

Christmas Prize Draw 2017
This photo is here for critique. Please only comment constructively and with suggestions on how to improve it.


Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

Tooth 12 5.8k 227 Ireland
15 Aug 2010 2:58PM
"..might make a good silhouette, but wondered if it might qualify as one..."

No absolute rules of course, but I think silhouettes should be just that or not - ie they should be black with no detail in the shadows, or failing that brightened with significant detail pulled out of the shadows. In this case it's not quite black, with just a hint of detail in the shadows...and it ends up being frustrating as the eye wants to see more detail once there's a hint of it there (compounded in this case by Focus Man's good point about wanting to read the sign.

Focus man has shown that there is indeed a fair bit of detail in there. So, nice idea but maybe just not the best subject for silhouette-ish treatment

paulbroad 10 123 1198 United Kingdom
15 Aug 2010 4:14PM
The subjective thing again. I think you are starting to 'see' pictures now rather than just recording scenes, and you have seen this one well. I like what you have done, but I might increase the contrast a bit more to make it a true silhoette.

Frank's version is Ok, but takes it back to a snapshot of a signpost for me - the silhouette is a pictorial image which, for me works as a central composition.

As a pure silhouette - full black, you could then select the silhouette with the magic sellection brush easily, then paste it onto a dramatic sky in colour. Would really be worth it.

xwang 8 56 8
15 Aug 2010 4:49PM
Thank you Frank, I take your point, maybe this is not a good one for silhouette.
Thank you Stephen for telling me what silhouette is...I don't have much ideas about it.When I took the photo,I saw the simple shape against the moody sky...
Thank you Paul, the reason I saw this as a silhouette,because I've been unconciously influenced by your work.I don't have any idea of silhouette, but I think that yours are superb.It was your "Heading home" popped in my mind.Simply line, strong and powerful, mine is weak and messyGrin,thank you so much for telling me how to do it....
Thank you all again.
Eviscera 11 1.1k 149 United Kingdom
15 Aug 2010 6:00PM
It is rather "Lost" xiaoli.

Not sure if this is about the bird or the lines or the trees , its very "busy"

Not sure if you could have zoomed in to capture just the bird on the signs or waited for it to fly off and concentrate on the signpost.

Either way , the left signpost touching the bushes was always going to spoil the composition. One to try a new p.o.v maybe !
xwang 8 56 8
15 Aug 2010 6:48PM
Ah... thank you Dave,I gave it a crop, is it better?
I am not sure about the composition. I'd like to have your advices.
Thank you again.
pamelajean Plus
11 1.0k 1966 United Kingdom
15 Aug 2010 6:54PM
Well, Xiaoli, I like it. I think you really wanted this to be a silhouette, especially after seeing your own modifications. I have taken one of them, used curves to strengthen the silhouette, then cloned some bits of cloud into the bright white sky area, and gave it some colour (2 mods). Go to Adjust>Hue and Saturation>Colorize and play with the sliders.
paulbroad 10 123 1198 United Kingdom
16 Aug 2010 7:49AM
Thanksd for the message - I've just done a mod myself - something I don't normally have time to do, but as we have talked - here it is - a real sky.

I increased contrast to pure B&W - selected all that was black, copied it, then pasted it onto a stock image of a real sky. Only time to defringe, but should give you the idea.

All the best,

pamelajean Plus
11 1.0k 1966 United Kingdom
17 Aug 2010 1:38PM
An excellent idea of Paul's and the mods look amazing.
Your mod is very good, too, Xiaoli.
You have learnt something else today.
xwang 8 56 8
17 Aug 2010 8:32PM
Thank Pamela, thank you Paul,thank everybody for your kind help, MODs and excellent ideas.I'm really very happy indeed,from not knowing what silhouette was to manage to make up one,it's all down to your kind help.I appreciate it very much.
Thank you all again.
Brilane 11 5 12 Wales
18 Aug 2010 9:04PM
I think that you have hit the spot with the picture and the title. The composition is excellent, the lonely, (lost), bird sitting on the signpost, and the signpost, itself, in silhouette, giving the the observer the impression of being lost and not being able to find, (see), their way.
I think that this picture is a perfect example of a picture with a 'meaning'.
Great composition and loved the modifications so far, well done Xiaoli !

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.