Views: 225 (79 Unique)  Award Shortlist   

"More or Less"

By RonnieAG
The same rose bud, shot indoors at the KS studio, with different cameras, with different lighting and at different times of the day: I wonder which works better, More or Less?

V 1: MORE.......Nikon D7000 in morning light.
V 2: LESS........Sony NEX-7 in afternoon light.

My thanks for all comments on Back to the Stables, and special thanks to Fred {Badgerfred} for his UA.

Ronnie.

Tags: Nikon Flowers Sony Pink Rose Flowers and plants Bud Indoor shot Available daylight only Black card bandg White card reflector

Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS
  • REVIEWS
  • INSPIRATION
  • COMMUNITY
  • COMPETITIONS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


USA Landscape Photographer of the Year 2016 open to entries NOW!

Comments


gary_d Plus
8 576 13 Wales
28 Aug 2012 12:12AM
Two great images Ronnie but I am favouring V1 for the fuller composition and light. - gary

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

annettep38 Plus
5 218 40 Costa Rica
28 Aug 2012 12:25AM
very difficult question, they both have their true merits. Both have excellent colours and detail
I feel slightly more attracted to the softer morning light and the complementary green. It makes the fine reds stand out even more.
mikbee 9 3 8 Scotland
28 Aug 2012 12:28AM
More for me in this case Ronnie.
And I do think the Nikon has the sharper detail,
but perhaps no surprises there !!
Mick.
taggart Plus
12 46 13 United States
28 Aug 2012 1:33AM
V1 absolutely--- v2 seems forced and in your face-- both skillfully accomplished, but v1 is a picture!
gazlowe 4 8 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 5:13AM
love it
CarolG Plus
9 195 18 Greece
28 Aug 2012 5:32AM
More for me, Ronnie, though both are beautiful images in their own right. Carol
NDODS Plus
5 4.9k 125 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 6:04AM
I have always been somewhat of greedy chap, so I shall opt for more "Please". "Stunning beauty, sumptuous colours, and sublime detail, what more could I possible ask for?"

Regards Nathan
fentiger Plus
15 916 23 England
28 Aug 2012 7:06AM
Either because they are both beautifully composed and presented images but if I have to choose it is No. 1.

Albert
netta1234 Plus
4 354 2 Wales
28 Aug 2012 7:11AM
2 Beautiful images of a lovely Rose ,If I had to choose it would be more.
Netta
28 Aug 2012 7:22AM
Version 1 does it for me..........it has more impact, better composition and better lighting........it is more pleasing to the eye........there is more action if you know what I mean.........WinkWinkWinkWink
SUE118 Plus
8 8 1 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 7:22AM
I can smell the scent from here, lovely image.
rontear Plus
13 8 7 England
28 Aug 2012 7:36AM
Excellent studies of this rose Ronnie, certainly a specialist.
Ron.
28 Aug 2012 7:38AM
Its beautifully captured. Its more i think. Deep
CaroleS Plus
6 421 3 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 7:46AM
Two completely different results. I do prefer V1 I love the colour and definition.
Carole
morpheus1955 9 3 2 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 7:51AM
Two beautiful images Ronnie, fabulous colours and excellent detail, beautifully captured and presented.

Hugh
Both very attractive. I prefer V1 with the leaves.
canonfan 6 7 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 8:07AM
Two excellent images Ronnie You have captured both beautifully and presented them well. Which is better?. A difficult one to answer both are equal to me
Jim
EAS 7 1 13 Scotland
28 Aug 2012 8:11AM
Has to be V1, though V2 is very pretty.

Ann
Lillian Plus
7 21 17 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 8:20AM
Going to say V1 Ronnie as the composition with the leaves included makes such
a beautiful capture, Like the light just coming through the rose petal
at top..beautifully done Ronnie
Lillian
EMJAYCEE Plus
7 9 10 England
28 Aug 2012 8:33AM
The inclusion of the foliage in V1 puts it in the lead Ronnie, although the light on the rose in V2 makes it a strong contender. Both are very lovely.
Joan.
28 Aug 2012 8:35AM
V1 is my favourite ... but both excellent images
Both have something going for them but for me V1 is my favourite. more in this case works well IMO.

John
jdinne 13 16 England
28 Aug 2012 9:42AM
Think both cameras have done well Ronnie. Both great, V1 for me though.

John
28 Aug 2012 10:05AM
hmmm confuddlement here Ronnie not sure i will come back i'm going to join the two shots together and look see again, will send you a copy of the joining

GrahamGrinGrinGrin
28 Aug 2012 10:33AM
ok ok already, having joined the two, and cast a blood shot eye over them V2 for me i like the colour saturation

GrahamGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin
28 Aug 2012 11:02AM
Amazing difference in the colour temperature Ronnie, I prefer the composition and the colour in V1.
It seems I have quite a way to go to catch up with the master of KS flower photography.

Dougie
achieverswales 6 8 101 Wales
28 Aug 2012 11:03AM
Has to be V1 for me Ronnie, both up to your usual quality standards, as stated the Nikon is sharper, but on flowers the softness works also, bit surprised on your choice of lens for the Nikon when you have that fantastic macro lens.

Regards

Trev.
Irishkate Plus
5 38 98 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 11:19AM
Very often I strip off leaves but in this case I'm with the majority
The light is more subtle also. A beautiful rose.
KateGrinGrinGrin
WhiteRose1 Plus
6 1.6k 148 England
28 Aug 2012 11:28AM
Both good Ronnie and a difficult question (well, at least the answer is difficult Tongue). Think I have to go with v2, less fussy and a softer feel to the image.

Dave

Quote:Both good Ronnie and a difficult question (well, at least the answer is difficult Tongue). Think I have to go with v2, less fussy and a softer feel to the image.

Dave



Lovely Ronnie.

PamGrinGrinGrin
Billyray 8 70 3 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 2:34PM
Two excellent shots Ronnie but V2 gets my user award. I prefer the closer shot and the composition.
Ray
TrevBatWCC Plus
8 12 10 England
28 Aug 2012 3:45PM
Two great captures and presentations, Ronnie, but it has to be V1 for me also Wink
Trev Smile
1881 4 India
28 Aug 2012 4:05PM
-EXCELLENT- shot.


=============== SANJEEV
pamelajean Plus
10 964 1824 United Kingdom
28 Aug 2012 5:35PM
V1 for the composition, Ronnie, if I have to make a choice.
28 Aug 2012 6:21PM
V1 for me Ronnie, I like to see more of the Leaves on a Rose. ( Don't ask why, I just do) Wink


John Smile
xwang 7 55 8
28 Aug 2012 6:26PM
I'm not sure.. V1 is more natural;V2 blends in with dark background better, I think.Smile
Ade_Osman 13 4.5k 36 England
28 Aug 2012 6:46PM
Unmistakably one of yours Ronnie....

Ade
Glyn1 7 4 1 England
28 Aug 2012 7:30PM
Two real beauties Ronnie, but there is just something about V1 which i find more appealing Wink I think maybe V2 is a little too close, but as I saod both are crackers.

Glyn
Superb images Ronnie, beautifully captured
Gordon
moiral 6 12 Scotland
28 Aug 2012 10:20PM
Prefer the first version Ronnie. Beautiful. Moira
howdog Plus
7 25 1 United Kingdom
29 Aug 2012 5:58AM
V2 for me Ronnie, Outstanding work.
Iain
mhfore 9 6 176 England
29 Aug 2012 12:34PM
Hi Ronnie,

I don't think you can chose one over the other as being the best as they are both to your usual high standard. As a preference though I have to go for V1, can you ask an easier qustion next time Wink

Take care
Martin
29 Aug 2012 5:33PM
Two stunning images Ronnie,beautiful captures..Lin
Glostopcat 10 255 2 England
29 Aug 2012 6:59PM
I prefer the bigger picture in v1, it looks more professional and you can tell that more thought has gone into producing this image. Not that there is anything wrong with v2 mind, it is nice in its own way
NeilWigan Plus
6 12 15 England
30 Aug 2012 11:10PM
V1 Ronnie.
31 Aug 2012 10:38AM
A difficult choice but I would go with V1.
Cliff
31 Aug 2012 6:13PM
Ronnie, stunning dof, with lovely clarity and colour tones.


Paul.
exposure 12 3.7k England
31 Aug 2012 8:42PM
Two beautiful images Ronnie...I do love V1
Pauline.
Niknut Plus
6 1.2k 68 United Kingdom
1 Sep 2012 4:18PM
Beautiful !!....lovely soft light !
Soooooooo beautiful Ronnie
Julie Grin

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.