Views: 133 (50 Unique) 
Vote 22
Award Shortlist   

Needle & Thread

By Take-a-View
Not that happy with this but thought I'd better get something uploaded for the "Critique Buddies June 2009 - 4" and look forward to critique.

Exposure 1 sec @ f36
ISO 200

Tags: Black and white Close-up and macro

Voters: jools59, bmh1, Growmore and 19 more

Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here

Exclusive 25% off Affinity Photo: Professional photo editing with no subscription!


Simon_Palmer 11 759 11 United Kingdom
27 Jun 2009 11:54AM
Not happy? I don't know why not. The detail is there, and it's well lit.

The background needs tidying if I'm being critical, looks like cotton fluff all over, a very simple thing to do in software.

Gets my vote, cos it's more exciting than most of the THREADS on the forums here Wink Sorry I couldn't resist.


Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

HectorRivera 10 17 1 United States
27 Jun 2009 3:36PM
Nice shot, great contrast and detail
Artois 12 405 1 United Kingdom
27 Jun 2009 5:31PM
I like the mono processing. An unusual subject matter! The composition works well. There is a loss of detail on the needle and thread toward the bottom of the image. I think the lighting has worked well leading the eye to the cotton reel. I do feel that the prescence of cotton fluff on the background lends itself to the subject matter. Overall I like this image for its simplicity.
jeanie Plus
14 6.0k 6 United Kingdom
27 Jun 2009 5:50PM
I would never have come up with this idea - its a good one, and the mono conversion works well. The end of the thread is nicely set up in that "s" shape curve there. The thread is not burnt out, you can see the textures. I have mixed thoughts about the fluff on the backdrop. One part of me says that when dressmaking there was always fluff about - well there was whenever I got the sewing machine out anyway! Smile. The other part of me says it would be nice to see a clean backdrop. I will have to sit on the fence on that.
Overall - I like it very much.
27 Jun 2009 6:52PM
Great Image.
Daisymaye Plus
9 23 16 Canada
28 Jun 2009 4:09AM
Unusual but a very good image........Sandy
EAS 9 1 13 Scotland
28 Jun 2009 9:01AM
I was struck by how well focused and clear it all seemed. Read the comments and still of the same opinion!!

camay 11 139 3 England
28 Jun 2009 10:35AM
I think you have an excellent photo here. I think it's beautifully sharp, and I love the detail in different areas, the texture of the thread, of the reel and the way the light catches it.
I saw the fluff on the background but to be honest thought it was on my screen and ignored it.
What I find mildly disturbing is the totally mono - tone of the background, it means the reel and thread appear to be suspended rather than sitting on a surface, and that goes against my practical mind. I wonder if it would be better if you could see a range of tones in the background, or at least that the needle and reel are sitting on a solid surface.

v8dunc 11 333 4 Scotland
28 Jun 2009 5:03PM
Nicely lit and well exposed,very simple image but still very interesting.Good sharp focus front to rear.Nice image

A Booth 16 11 4 United Kingdom
29 Jun 2009 11:45AM
simple but effective presentation, excellet detail.
phaz99 10 26 1 Scotland
29 Jun 2009 2:23PM
Crit Buddy:

I love the simplicity of this, it's a nice clean image which I think would look great as a blown up print/canvas on the wall.

Although the background 'fluff' isnt instantly noticable I think it would be better to clone it out to ensure a crisp black background, unlike lynne I like how it seems to be floating, I think it adds to the image's simplicity and sharpness.

A very successful image!

NEWMANP 10 1.6k 574 United Kingdom
1 Jul 2009 11:14PM
i like the composition here and the decision to go mono was a good call.
the shape and needle work well and the plain black ground add to its strength.
nice shot, like it a lot,

i filled up the group at the last minute.
barbarahirst 9 27 12 United Kingdom
30 Sep 2009 3:23PM
Think this is a belter
I love the fact that it looks suspended
Great work
hasu Plus
10 8 United Kingdom
7 Feb 2011 3:36PM
Very good capture! I would have clean the dust spots before uploading.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.