Back Modifications (2)
Views: 88 (42 Unique)  Award Shortlist   

river dee in the snow

By bigbirdr7
Take on the meadows looking ovr the River Dee

Tags: General Architecture Landscape and travel

Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here

PortraitPro 17 SITEWIDE 50% off sale + EXTRA 15% OFF code EPZR18
This photo is here for critique. Please only comment constructively and with suggestions on how to improve it.


cantona43 Plus
12 925 4 England
15 Jan 2010 11:40PM
a wonderful shot super reflections the one thing that spoils this shot for me is you have your shadow in the foreground

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

16 Jan 2010 12:02AM
Hi cantona,
thanks for the feedback didn`t spot the shadow it is a distraction i agree.

certx 11 415 1 United States
16 Jan 2010 4:11AM
Yup, the shadow is definitely a distraction, and probably the first thing I saw when I looked at the foreground. But aside from that my initial response was that I like the shot.

As a thought, I wonder what it would have looked like with the waterline on the far shore a little higher in the frame. Maybe even shot from kneeling or lying down on the ground right at the waters edge. Would have made for some nice looong reflections.

young_al 9 5 England
16 Jan 2010 11:15AM
tried cropping the image down a bit, there was quite a lot of sky but not much actually happening in it, no clouds for you unfortunately.
removed a bit of foreground too as i thought it might make what was left of the shadow a little less distracting???

tried to lighten the shadow also but not sure it really worked on the jpeg.... tiny bit of colour boost to get some vibrance in the sky

hope thats ok.
16 Jan 2010 1:36PM
I'm just a beginner but I wondered if you could just clone out the shadow in Photoshop? Otherwise I liked this very much. I agree a shot from kneeling or lying down would have been worth seeing.
16 Jan 2010 8:54PM
Hi annmackiemiller,
thanks for the comment as i have said to other members i need to practice on the photoshop.My husband is always saying to me get down lower to the scene i think i need to do as i am told.i will try and put my efforts on this site for more comments

malc_c 11 2 167 England
17 Jan 2010 4:37AM
Hi Sylvia,
You have a nice tranquil shot here, capturing the stillness of the riverside blanketed in snow. Your shadow in the foreground is an issue as had been well covered, but actually the whole foreground is superfluous...

You already have depth to the image because of the reflections, and scale because of familiar objects such as houses and boats. So we're left with the foreground being little more than a big bright distraction. What's more, getting rid of it simplifies the image and lets us see what you are portraying more clearly.

Obviously this should be 'fixed' through composition, but I have posted a mod where I have cropped and cloned as appropriate to illustrate. I also-
  • cropped much of the sky (in fact you could probably remove a little more) to give something of a letterbox presentation
  • used a curves adjustment to give a little more contrast
  • progressively darkened the sky with a levels adjustment and a layer mask to hold the image in at the top- again not too much to make it shout out

Hope this helps,
17 Jan 2010 1:23PM
Hi Malcolm,
Thank s for the comments you have done an amazing job on my photo.I am trying to get on with photoshop but not doing very well.I trying to follow the great advice i am receiving from everyone .At the moment i am taking in the comments on shooting at a lower level and making sure i don`t shot anything such as my own shadow.Thanks again for a great improvememt.
malc_c 11 2 167 England
17 Jan 2010 5:32PM
Hi Sylvia,
Don't be too prescriptive over the 'shoot low' comments. In a case like this shooting from a low viewpoint would reduce the space the water took up in the image, and in return that would reduce the space for the reflections. As the reflections rather make this image, that may not be a good thing. On the other hand if there was something boring such as pavement there, reducing or even hiding it by adopting a low viewpoint would be just what you wanted.

As an example, if you look at my 'Whitby Abbey' picture ( I even stretched the foreground in photoshop to increase the size of the lake for balance. Of course, if had had a step ladder at my disposal....

ps thanks for the constructive critique vote.
20 Jan 2010 7:59AM
Sylvia - thanks for the constructive critique vote

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.