Views: 92 (33 Unique) 
Vote 27
Award Shortlist   

Trail to the Summit

By Guillaume
Having taken a hard look at all three shots, my preference is for the b/w version cropped in a square format - the composition better follows the rule of third. Unfortunately, I downsized the picture too much and lost resolution. I will re-post a higher quality version this evening.

Let me know which one you prefer in the meantime, I am interested in your views.

Thanks for watching.

Tags: Mountain Lake Italy Black and white Trail Matterhorn Landscape and travel Cervinia Wildlife and nature

Voters: PepeC, PeterBee, javam and 24 more


Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS
  • REVIEWS
  • INSPIRATION
  • COMMUNITY
  • COMPETITIONS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here


Comments


PeterBee 10 35 5 United Kingdom
7 Dec 2007 10:03AM
Yes, I think I agree with your assessment that the square format version is the best one.

Peter

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

TyChee Plus
11 273 1 United States
7 Dec 2007 11:59AM
Nice set of images. I like number 2 the best.
Ty
7 Dec 2007 12:58PM
Excellent image, mono tones are superb, love the colour version to

Graeme
HowardA 9 231
7 Dec 2007 1:02PM
Well, I'll go against the grain and opt for 1 & 3. Whichever one you go for it's certainly a very beautiful scene with plenty of interesting elements.
Howard
joolsb 11 27.1k 38 Switzerland
7 Dec 2007 1:47PM
I'd go for the comp from 2 with the colours of 3. Nice work, whichever one you prefer!
GalleryGirl 8 4 2 United Kingdom
7 Dec 2007 3:47PM
I like No. 3 I think the colour gives more detail but do like the b/w ones too.
Marilyn x
woolybill1 Plus
9 19 66 United Kingdom
7 Dec 2007 4:41PM
Never mind rules, the b/w version of #3 has lost shadow detail on the right evident in the original. Generally I find the square version better balanced with a greater proportion of interest.
Bill
Guillaume 9 119 2 United Kingdom
7 Dec 2007 5:10PM
Thanks to all for your comments! I am glad to see everybody disagree Smile Smile
Woolybill1 is right. Some of the shadow details on the right have been lost. That's a PS job for me tonight: bringing more of the details out. If I get something decent, I will post it.
riprap007 11 1.6k 37 England
7 Dec 2007 5:18PM
prefer 3 as I think that a better mono conversion could be done, #1 has not got enough separation with the fir tree and BG mountain
7 Dec 2007 6:08PM
lovely shot I like #3 however 2-1 are great
AnneWorner 8 620 43 United States
7 Dec 2007 6:30PM
Beautiful composition. I am attracted to the square format of version 2, but love the color version most.
Anne
dclarke5 13 147 United Kingdom
8 Dec 2007 12:32PM
Yep No2 for me.
Guillaume 9 119 2 United Kingdom
8 Dec 2007 1:35PM
Number 4, with more details in the shadows has finally been uploaded. Thanks everyone for the advices!
Diana 9 2.0k 19 Netherlands
10 Dec 2007 10:03AM
1 and 4

Dianna
banehawi Plus
11 1.4k 3422 Canada
11 Dec 2007 8:36PM
# 4 for me, - this shot is well suited to B&W

W

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.