Back Modifications (0)
Views 77 Unique 22
Vote 22
Award Shortlist   

Tulip Test 2

By conrad  
As requested, a version of this image in which the pattern of the background was not made an overlay on top of the flower.

So far, I still think the previous upload was more "special" and interesting - this is just a flower in front of a backlit background.

But of course I am interested to hear your (detailed) opinion. And mods are welcome, too.

Thanks for looking,

Conrad

Tags: Test Paper Background Tulip Flowers and plants Digitally manipulated Blend Overlay

Voters: lifesnapper, User_Removed, jeanie and 19 more


Exclusive ePHOTOzine offer - 20% off Mistubishi CP-M15E Bundle!

Comments


User_Removed 15 32 United Kingdom
16 Jun 2006 11:31AM
Strange as it may seem, to my eye this one looks more like a piece of artwork than the previous one, but they are both extremely good pieces of work

Jeff
cdm36 16 391 7 England
16 Jun 2006 11:41AM
Would have to be the other for me, Smile.


Chris.
imagegrill 14 429
16 Jun 2006 11:42AM
I think your right, the other one with the background pattern is best, though neither really do it for me. Painting 'effect' photo's just don't cut it my wya I'm afraid though I do appreciate the work and effort gone into this Smile
conrad 16 10.9k 116
16 Jun 2006 11:49AM
Thanks, Jeff, Chris and Paul!

Paul, it isn't meant to be a painting effect, really. Especially not this particular upload, because no pattern has been put in or on the flower. This is just a piece of backlit paper on a lightbox, shot separately from the flower, and then the flower was put on top of the paper. Just to give it an interesting background. My previous upload was indeed intended to be a bit more arty, although the same "real ingredients" were used. But thanks for giving me your honest opinion, I really appreciate that!

Conrad
16 Jun 2006 11:56AM
wow...great wall hanger..congratulations
starliz 16 1.6k 3 England
16 Jun 2006 12:10PM
I do like this one the tulip is a beautiful colour and seems to have a nice satin look to it sorry not to keen on the green of the leaves against the BG but overall it is a lovely,my preference is definitely the other has a much more refined look to me.
highlander 16 32 Scotland
16 Jun 2006 12:13PM
Has a beautiful artistic side to your flower Conrad...different and well presented.
Doug.
franken Plus
18 5.1k 4 United Kingdom
16 Jun 2006 12:28PM
This is excellent work I think I prefer this to yesterdays. Well composed. The colours and the texture in the background is very good.

regards
Ken
akh Plus
16 1.2k 5 United Kingdom
16 Jun 2006 1:10PM
I like the way you have co-ordinated the BG colour with the flower but have to agree that the previous upload had a more special feel to it.
Tony
turtle1 16 41 United Kingdom
16 Jun 2006 1:12PM
I prefer this one, the tulip still blends in with the background, but the tulip is the focal point, as how it should be. Super work.

Barb
16 Jun 2006 11:08PM
Hi Conrad, Another good one of these shots, really nice marriage with the background. Fabulous idea, well executed. helen
ann_g 16 19 United Kingdom
16 Jun 2006 11:17PM
Have to be the odd one out, I prefer the other one. One idea might be to fade the overlay on the flower just slightly so the flower is a little more visible. A layer mask could do that, might be worth trying. Lovely effect.

Ann Smile
User_Removed 15 4.3k 2 United Kingdom
17 Jun 2006 12:09AM
I love the textures on this Conrad - the petals look like silk.
conrad 16 10.9k 116
17 Jun 2006 1:11AM
Ha! Divided opinions, I knew that would happen!

Thanks, everyone! Glad you're giving your opinions honestly and in detail.

Ann - Sounds like a good idea, I'll add it to the list of ideas (which is growing...). Thanks!

Conrad
TopsyTopping 14 51 United Kingdom
20 Jun 2006 8:59PM
This is my favourite out of all of them because i love the background and i like to see the sharpness of the flower too! Gorgeous orange too!

Topsy Smile
conrad 16 10.9k 116
21 Jun 2006 6:54AM
Thanks, Topsy!

C.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.