Back Modifications (2)
Views 169 Unique 25
Vote 25
Award Shortlist   

Stump

By claret
Really struggling for anything half decent to post. Back to the conifers or at least half a conifer. Tried removing the tree in the middle of the shot but couldn't do it without it looking obvious. More thought about composition required.

Tags: Landscape and travel

Voters: riprap007, simont, User_Removed and 22 more


PortraitPro Sale - 50% Off + Save An Extra 20% With Code: ZBFV23
ADVERTISEMENT

Comments


riprap007 18 1.6k 37 England
12 Jan 2005 7:12AM
the tree in the middle does get in the way of the composition, however great tonal quality to this image.
simont 18 2.3k 4 United Kingdom
12 Jan 2005 7:14AM
Like the stump in the middle.
Not sure about the tree in the middle. On one hand it's distracting from the lone stump - which is great, while on the other hand it draws my eye up, back to the path to see what else there is along it.
Click
Simon
Pete 21 18.8k 97 England
12 Jan 2005 7:35AM
I agree about the centre tree, also the background may help if it's slightly blurred. I've popped up a modified version. It's rough cloning, so you can see the patches, but it shows how I'd probably handle it.
User_Removed 18 386 2 United Kingdom
12 Jan 2005 7:36AM
Good detail and composition.
Click!

Lucien.
claret 18 49 England
12 Jan 2005 7:39AM
Thanks Lucien, Simon and Nicholas. Think I prefer Pete's version. Thanks for the quick work, Pete. More practice at cloning me thinks, or better still take a better shot in the first place!.
phiggy 21 7 United Kingdom
12 Jan 2005 7:49AM
Super detail lovely woodland scene.
Phil
andytvcams 20 10.4k 1 United Kingdom
12 Jan 2005 7:51AM
Loverly saturated colours of the fern makes this jump out,

i removed the tree but lost a little of the saturation during the upload?.

Andy...
claret 18 49 England
12 Jan 2005 7:53AM
Thanks Phil.
Again quick work, Andy. Thanks for that.
suleesia 18 176 Malaysia
12 Jan 2005 7:55AM
Lovely composition, very nice colour.
Su
pjcurran 18 6
12 Jan 2005 7:57AM
Nice colours Iain, Hom many men does it take to get rid of a tree! LOL Clicked
karenpics 18 2
12 Jan 2005 9:30AM
I like the colours well done Click Karen
helen&peter 18 98
12 Jan 2005 9:49AM
Nice shot but I like it better with the tree cloned out. Click
Helen
glazzaro 17 70 23 United States
12 Jan 2005 6:41PM
I like it! I think the photo focuses on the old and leads you into the new! Good Shot! Click!!!
claret 18 49 England
12 Jan 2005 11:57PM
Thanks Greg, Helen, Karen, Peadar and Su.
pfheyes 18 254 1 United Kingdom
13 Jan 2005 12:17AM
Hi Iain, I agree with the comments about the tree, but being presented with such a cloning job, I'd probably not bother. Too much like hard work! Smile

I think you had chosen an interesting subject, and part from the tree distraction, it's well composed. Maybe a couple of inches to the left next time.

All the best,

Pete
claret 18 49 England
13 Jan 2005 12:19AM
Thanks Pete. On reflection probably shouldn't have posted this but very short of decent shots at the moment and its hard to resist the temptation to post something!
johnjrp 18 432 5 Australia
13 Jan 2005 12:56AM
Great composition and colours. John
click
claret 18 49 England
13 Jan 2005 1:13AM
Thanks John.
elaine max 18 5
13 Jan 2005 4:51AM
The modified versions are good but I like your image too
Click
Elaine x
claret 18 49 England
13 Jan 2005 7:15AM
Thanks Elaine.
13 Jan 2005 8:22AM
Good shot, Iain. Take the chainsaw next time! Click
Jules
A Booth 20 11 4 United Kingdom
13 Jan 2005 8:25AM
excellent visually, superb colours and composition.
claret 18 49 England
13 Jan 2005 1:37PM
Thanks Jules and Alan.
markthompson 18 13 United Kingdom
15 Jan 2005 7:44AM
Great strong composition. Good use of DOF.
Mark
claret 18 49 England
15 Jan 2005 11:57AM
Thanks Mark.
highlander 18 32 Scotland
16 Jan 2005 6:43AM
Hello Iain, I like the green bracken in front of the stump the way it contrasts...the actual wood and grasses are nice and colourful. Good shot.
Doug.
claret 18 49 England
16 Jan 2005 11:48PM
Thanks Doug.
gwyn h 18 432
17 Jan 2005 4:55AM
Missed this one when you uploaded it Iain.

So easy to be wise after the event isn't it, however I don't feel any of the modifed versions work without the tree. If you'd just moved those few inches when taking it you'd have ended up with a cracker IMHO. Still all part of the learning curve, and a nice lesson for us all here I think. Thanks for uploading it.

Gwyn
tartanlady 18 58 Scotland
17 Jan 2005 7:07AM
I like the light and the colour in this shot Iain, I agree with Gwyn, how often just a small step to the side helps the composition but hindsight is a great thing. Smile
Louise
claret 18 49 England
17 Jan 2005 8:00AM
Thanks Gwyn and Louise.
lyne 18 15
18 Jan 2005 3:50PM
Beautiful lighting and colours excellent shot lynex
claret 18 49 England
18 Jan 2005 11:50PM
Thanks Lyne.
Gary_Macleod 18 166 Scotland
23 Feb 2005 3:46AM
i do like this...would like to see some closer detail in B&W.....or this image in B&W...Click

Gary
claret 18 49 England
23 Feb 2005 4:07AM
Thanks Gary. Will have a look.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.

ADVERTISEMENT