Back Versions (1)
Modifications (0)
Views 136 Unique 82
Vote 64
Award Shortlist   
PortraitPro 22 Save An Extra 20% With Code: EZJ22

Comments


5 Oct 2021 8:03AM
I think you've created something spectacular!
Tony
5 Oct 2021 8:29AM
Stunning lead capture, ivor.

Mike
AlfieK Plus
4 1 1 United Kingdom
5 Oct 2021 8:39AM
Creative and very clever.
Alfie
RonDM Plus
7 261 United Kingdom
5 Oct 2021 8:43AM
I really like what you have done great work

Ron
5 Oct 2021 8:51AM
Excellent work Ivor,
Fred.
suemart Plus
4 4 2 United Kingdom
5 Oct 2021 8:53AM
The fake is fine by me! Pure joy Smile
I fully agree with your view
Quote:For me it's just an enjoyable exercise in image making in which the camera is just a part.
bliba Plus
16 2 Austria
5 Oct 2021 8:54AM
such a beautiful scene , IvorWink
very well manipulated Wink
PhilT2 Plus
12 575 32 England
5 Oct 2021 8:57AM
You have created a silk purse from a sows ear...... Very well done Ivor
Does an artist create a fake when choosing what to include on his canvas. Photography is an art form to use as you please and always has been. Modern software has given us all the opportunity to become artists.
Nikonuser1 Plus
9 170 16 United Kingdom
5 Oct 2021 8:57AM
A great piece of manipulation IvorSmileSmileSmile

Cliff
5 Oct 2021 9:28AM
An art in itself, Ivor and a wonderful ability to create something more than a basic scene.
Much like an artist would add a flower, a tree or maybe a boat to a painting.
It's not called; the art of deception for nothing you know... Wink

JohnSmile
FabioKeiner 9 111 1 Austria
5 Oct 2021 9:55AM
excellent
dales Plus
6 13 Australia
5 Oct 2021 10:32AM
Most definitely art Ivor & you have created a magnificent example
Ian
adagio Plus
3 4 2 England
5 Oct 2021 11:37AM
For me, the camera is the artist's tool providing something purely to work with. What you have created from the original image is wonderful, and just goes to show what can be done.

Angela😀
chase Plus
16 2.3k 601 England
5 Oct 2021 12:15PM
Creating something from nothing is an Art in itself.
Cleverly and very effectively created Ivor.
5 Oct 2021 1:32PM
awesome result and you have fun in the process Smile
Chinga Plus
11 3 2 United Kingdom
5 Oct 2021 1:45PM
The way you present the sky in the lead shot is spectacular...
Good boatabilia image. Isabel GrinGrin
Daisymaye Plus
13 23 21 Canada
5 Oct 2021 1:51PM
Being an artist on a computer. Beats having paint and brushes and a lot of mess. A beautiful image created from a ordinary scene Ivor.
Mollycat Plus
8 21 2 United Kingdom
5 Oct 2021 2:24PM
Imaginative and creative Ivor.
Peter
cooky Plus
18 6 6 United Kingdom
5 Oct 2021 3:02PM
Think everyone is in agreement Ivor! Think whatever way we arrive at an image, we all trying to create an image people will appreciate. You have done just that - good on yer! SmileSmile

Kath
5 Oct 2021 3:50PM
Wow Ivor. The difference is staggering. I love the image you’ve created.

Karen
5 Oct 2021 4:13PM
Cracker Ivor - brilliant processing !
5 Oct 2021 4:57PM
Defintely art (and first class processing skills).
5 Oct 2021 6:19PM
Art of fake? I don't care. The lead version is great and I applaud your imagination and processing skills.
pamelajean Plus
16 1.7k 2243 United Kingdom
5 Oct 2021 7:55PM
Sometimes it's hard to know how much work someone has done on an image to make it really good.
Part of me wants to know. Part of me thinks it doesn't matter. The end result is the important thing.
We now have so much software to play with. It would be crazy to ignore it.
Working on the Critique Team, we are constantly asking to see the original. This way we can critique the work that has been done, and also offer alternative processing suggestions.
I was truly impressed when I first saw your lead image and then, seeing the original, I was gobsmacked !
BobinAus Plus
6 3 11 Australia
6 Oct 2021 1:29AM
Well, we'd all have much less art to enjoy if shortcuts or deviations from 'reality' were prohibited. But somewhere in the grey area between artistry and fakery, I think it makes some difference whether the substitute sky was captured by the photographer who displays the work or taken from another source. In this case Ivor, you've replaced the sky skillfully so that there's not too much competition between its brilliant colours and the more subdued light that you've given to the main subjects which in reality would be simple silhouettes against that new dawning sun.

Also, I'm not sure that the version should be dismissed as a sow's ear. I won't be too surprised to see it again with the original sky at some time in the future, presented with an appealing minor key treatment. Bob

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.