Back Modifications (1)
Views: 91 (69 Unique)  Award Shortlist   


By Harpic
Goldfinch about to land on thistle head.
cropped from the original and noise reduced (pic taken @ iso 800)

Tags: Flight Goldfinch Bird Wildlife and nature

Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here

This photo is here for critique. Please only comment constructively and with suggestions on how to improve it.


RTR 8 8 8 United Kingdom
22 Mar 2010 8:17PM
I think the problem here is over sharpening. This is an excellent composition, but is extremely difficult to do (I've never managed it, and have yet to master birds that sit still!). What you could do to try and save it, is select the bird, inverse the selection and wind the noise right down on all the background. If that fails you could always blur the background. It may then be ok to print at 6x4. Great colours. The shot just shows how very frustrating our hobby realy is! You think you've got the shot, get home and ... damn, just not quite right.
Fantastic effort though, Rich.

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

super composition.ray
DerekL Plus
13 188 24 England
22 Mar 2010 9:06PM
You will get a slight increase in grain at ISO800, but nowhere near as much as is visible in this image. I think that you have cropped the image too much from the original. This has caused the overall graininess and lack of detail in the image. Also the focus point is in front of the bird, in the same plain as the 2nd thistle head on the left.

I hope you do not feel I have been harsh, but I have tried to offer you constructive critique to improve your images.
iancatch 11 4 45 England
23 Mar 2010 3:25AM

Did you mean to freeze the action as the wings tips are slightly blurred? Secondly the noise for me spoils the shot. As suggested at ISO 800 you will get some graining but I also think this has come from quite a substantial crop. Also I'm not sure that 300mm is large enough when photographing birds. I have a 300 lens and I have never managed to get a decent bird shot. Also the image of the bird or part of needs to be crisp and sharp and I dont see that here. Again I thnk this is due to a large crop - it would be interesting to see the original.

Harpic 7 13 England
23 Mar 2010 7:28PM
Many thanks for the comments, it's nice to get some decent honest criticism. I think all the comments hit the mark, it was an enlarged crop from a relatively small area and the sharpening was done with picture project. I've since got CS4 and might getter better results. Some of my other shots that I'll upload have also been through the Picture project package, so apologies if, they to seem over sharp !.
I love the challenge of trying to get a decent bird shot (especially in flight) and until I can get a 500ish lens I'll have to hope I can get closer !.
Thaks again

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.