Views 87 Unique 35
Vote 32
Award Shortlist   
30-Day FREE Amazon Prime Trial - Get Ready For Prime Day 2021


imander 14 388 7 United Kingdom
1 Oct 2007 3:16PM
like the version you put up, really lovely looking
foggytwo 18 36 1 Scotland
1 Oct 2007 3:21PM
Both versions are great Kathy but I think you made the right choice.Those dark clouds over the golden foreground look super.
AlleyCatz 15 274 6 England
1 Oct 2007 3:23PM
Both are great images....but I do prefer the B&W.
Love that menacing sky.

BlueRoom 15 73 20 United Kingdom
1 Oct 2007 3:36PM
Oh... the colour. Subtle but so beautiful.

JouŠo 17 56 Finland
1 Oct 2007 3:41PM
great drama in the sky.......

PatrickSmith 16 1.2k 2 United States
1 Oct 2007 3:42PM
I like the coloured bersion. The sky is almost mono as it is and it really highlights the land well. Definitely not depressing and quite instructive.

Slaterm 15 496 1 United Kingdom
1 Oct 2007 3:50PM
both good but prefer the colour version - more moody somehow

riprap007 16 1.6k 37 England
1 Oct 2007 3:52PM
colour by far
Coleslaw 15 13.4k 28 Wales
1 Oct 2007 3:57PM
prefer mono...sorrySmile
MikeA 16 1.3k England
1 Oct 2007 4:04PM
Colour in this instance, nothing wrong with the mono, the colour creates more of a mood.

Nettles 14 England
1 Oct 2007 4:21PM
If I could give you two votes I would as both versions are great.
Super shot. Annette
danielle1987 15 64 United Kingdom
1 Oct 2007 4:57PM
Personally i prefer the colour as I think the field needs the colour. Interesting to see people's different opinions, both are great but its colour for me.
angej 16 479 United Kingdom
1 Oct 2007 7:06PM
Think I like the colour bestSmile
Barrynic 14 16
1 Oct 2007 7:37PM
Colour !
Dotrob 15 Wales
1 Oct 2007 7:47PM
Colour one for me, lovely colours and a super sky.
neonknight 16 1 United Kingdom
1 Oct 2007 7:55PM
Both look good maybe mono just edge's it nice one,John
proz 16 205 United States
1 Oct 2007 8:19PM
really awesome photo
ann_g 17 19 United Kingdom
1 Oct 2007 9:20PM
Coloue for me, great sky

Ann Smile
KathyW 17 1.8k 12 Norfolk Island
3 Oct 2007 5:26PM
Thanks everyone - I still can't really decide, but I think the colour one just has the edge... or not!

The farmer was pleased with his harvest pics anyway Smile

Thanks again
una 17 10 United Kingdom
4 Oct 2007 10:23PM
Beautiful shots but I prefer the colour one.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.