Views 275 Unique 133
Vote 91
Award Shortlist   
Save up to 360 on selected ZEISS lenses!

Comments


debu 9 India
15 Nov 2013 2:47PM
Super view.
debu

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

ChiliMan 13 135 17 Singapore
15 Nov 2013 2:48PM
Very fetching view, Keith, and that is some sky with those beautiful clouds. Great shot, but I must admit I prefer the original in V2 Smile

The clouds look better there to me, for one thing. More detail and nicer light there too.

Andrew
Nikonuser1 Plus
7 160 16 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 2:52PM
Great image, Keith like both imagesSmile

Cliff
Tish1 Plus
6 32 5 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 2:52PM
OOW that's a bit special, prefer V1 personally, so much more moody, love the composition and those clouds are very menacing, great shot in my humble opinion.

Tish
15 Nov 2013 2:56PM
Very nice moody shot
AnneWorner 12 620 43 United States
15 Nov 2013 3:00PM
Like the shot overall, and although it's close to monochromatic, I prefer v2 for the light/color on the distant trees.

Anne
15 Nov 2013 3:05PM
Two beautiful versions, Keith!SmileSmileSmile

Richard
15 Nov 2013 3:15PM
Both versions are great ! In my opinion V2 is better with more natural tones!
Regards,
George
ColleenA Plus
7 440 6 Australia
15 Nov 2013 3:17PM
A wonderful landscape...love the clouds...think the blue tones add something special to the scene...excellent capture
Mollycat Plus
6 21 2 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 3:17PM
Moody and manificent, both, but prefer one. Peter.
mikbee 12 3 8 Scotland
15 Nov 2013 3:36PM
Prefer the blue toned one here Keith.
If there was more colour in the original,
I would have preferred that I expect !!
Mick.
almiles 10 38 102 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 4:04PM
Looks like how they often shoot 'night' scenes in films! V1 does look quite like you shot it by moonlight which has a certain 'Twilight' feel. However, V2 does seem more real, and therefore more engaging. You get more cloud drama and more contrast and detail on the opposite shore and it's a stunning image! I'm very impressed by your toning skills though. Smile
SUE118 Plus
11 8 1 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 4:24PM
i like both but can't decide which is best. Super capture.
Jasper87 Plus
9 2.3k 158 England
15 Nov 2013 4:26PM
Wonderful drama in the clouds which echo the shape of the trees very nicely. The figures add a small but very significant element. Have to go with v2. Mono with a hint of green in the trees. Fine work, Keith.

Dave
AnnChown Plus
10 207 1 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 4:35PM
I prefer v2 too Keith - those hints of colour really work for me! Excellent shot - but there's nothing like a bit of fiddling to see what can be done! SmileSmile
JuBarney Plus
8 33 4 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 4:54PM
A beautiful image and love V1.
Ju
15 Nov 2013 5:09PM
V1 for me, stunning GrinGrin
Kathryn
taggart Plus
15 47 13 United States
15 Nov 2013 5:28PM
For this image, I like the blue toning--a great choice!
15 Nov 2013 5:53PM
Definitely V2 for me, IMNAAHO*
I also like toned monos, they can sometimes be very effective, and it's easy enough to bang a tone on and fiddle with it when you don't have to mess around with chemicals ( Thank you, God, for Photoshop! ), but here I feel that it adds nothing to what is an excellent image to start with. Agree with Dave about the figures.

Regards,
Alan

* "In-My-Not-At-All-Humble-Opinion" Grin
Fefe Plus
8 33 31 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 6:07PM
Oooooo blommin eck..... I cant decide, Love them bothGrinGrinGrin
Diane
helenlinda Plus
12 366 22 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 6:09PM
v2 for me here Keith SmileSmile
Helen
EileenH 6 1 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 6:09PM
Lovely image V2 for me :

Eileen
myrab 13 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 6:34PM
Two smashing images, but v2 ticks all the boxes for me.

Myra
Nigeve1 6 1.4k 101 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 7:40PM
Very impressive landscape image with superb light and excellent composition with two very well placed figures. I prefer V2 original.
Nigel
BIGRY1 7 3 8 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 8:27PM
I like both versions but V2 is my fav. That sky is pretty impressive tooWinkGrin
Ryan
The water ripples make this image for me.. Wonderful light captured.. Brilliant ...V1 for me
Irishkate Plus
9 41 116 United Kingdom
15 Nov 2013 10:22PM
I'm with the V2 original brigade. I like the warmer feel but a great image to play with
the dappled light and dramatic clouds. Good tonal range.
KateGrinGrinGrin
annettep38 Plus
8 219 42 Costa Rica
15 Nov 2013 10:47PM
hard to decide. I like them both, they have a totally different character like chalk and cheese, the contrast is the winner.
viscostatic 13 45 5 United Kingdom
16 Nov 2013 9:16AM
Very dramatic and beautiful Keith. I just loved V1 until I clicked on V2 and now I prefer it.

Phil.
RonnieAG Plus
10 154 119 Scotland
16 Nov 2013 11:23AM
A very attractive composition with V 2, the original, my favourite.
R.
JOKEN 10 3 10 United Kingdom
16 Nov 2013 1:24PM
Wow! Such digital drama. I think I prefer the blue mono version
Ken
CaroleS Plus
9 440 3 United Kingdom
16 Nov 2013 1:38PM
A wonderful comp and V1 for meSmile
AnnJ 8 5 Scotland
16 Nov 2013 2:53PM
V2 for me. Ann
jaktis 15 84 Sweden
16 Nov 2013 5:18PM
Dramatic composition

Peter
Tynnwrlluniau Plus
10 112 38 Wales
16 Nov 2013 6:39PM
Great comp here, Keith with the figures lending scale and emotion to the scene. Both are excellent but I prefer the toning of v1.
Alun
tomcat 14 6.4k 15 United Kingdom
16 Nov 2013 7:56PM
Magical

Adrian
carper123 Plus
8 1.2k 8 United Kingdom
16 Nov 2013 9:29PM
Two excellent variants, and a fine composition, v2 for me, that hint of colour is just gorgeous.
Nice one, Keith.
Darryl. SmileSmileSmile
PaulLiley 10 2 13 United Kingdom
17 Nov 2013 11:03AM
Wow thats got loads of atmosphere Keith. Its V1 for me. Love it. paul
Niknut Plus
9 2.4k 80 United Kingdom
17 Nov 2013 4:34PM
Paul...thankyou so much for the UA.......much appreciated !!
ChrisOs 14 2 1 United Kingdom
18 Nov 2013 4:30PM
Superb! Either one.
Chris
DixClix 10 2 United Kingdom
18 Nov 2013 7:06PM
Great image(s) but I think I prefer V2.
Richard
Maiwand 13 3 73 England
18 Nov 2013 7:31PM
Stunning shots Keith.GrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin
Ron
jacquig 6 3 United Kingdom
18 Nov 2013 10:34PM
Both beautiful images. Sky and composition both great. Gorgeous light. V1 for me, but hard to choose.
Glostopcat 13 255 2 England
22 Nov 2013 10:02PM
A very atmospheric scene with some fabulous cloud formations. I have a slight preference for v2 which is almost a mono with just a hint of colour in it

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.