Still Playing B&A by rpba18205

Save 15% On Excire Foto Software With Code: EXCIRE-EP

Comments

EAS 12 1 13

27 Mar 2010 1:48PM

Like 0

Colour and detail are much better in V1 so whatever it is you did, it worked!!

Ann

andylea 13 37 1

27 Mar 2010 1:52PM

Like 0

v1 for me today wonderful detail and colour nice one Wink

andy

BURNSIE 13 25 4

27 Mar 2010 2:02PM

Like 0

V1 is very good.
Regards
Burnsie

EMJAYCEE 12 10 10

27 Mar 2010 2:11PM

Like 0

V1 is nicely presented.
Joan.

maryg 13 66 18

27 Mar 2010 2:12PM

Like 0

Nice to see the before image as well. Like V1 but feel all the lovely colours and details of the flower are swamped by the strength/ richness of the background.Just my personal taste, off course, i think I might have either gone for black or very pastel tones behind the flower.

Regards Mary

maryg on 27 Mar 2010 2:12PM Constructive Critique

johnjones 12

27 Mar 2010 2:14PM

Like 0

great shot v1 as got the vote from me brill
jj

RajaSidambaram 11

27 Mar 2010 2:57PM

Like 0

Well manipulated & presented V1 - Raja.

gerrymac 14 10 1

27 Mar 2010 3:01PM

Like 0

A triffid......nice colour...agree with Mary about b'g....I prefer v2 ...nice job
Gerry

Bob_V 14 1 2

27 Mar 2010 3:14PM

Like 0

Wonderful color and presentation, V1 for me.
Bob

rpba18205 Plus

11 1 4

27 Mar 2010 4:13PM

Like 0

Quote:Nice to see the before image as well. Like V1 but feel all the lovely colours and details of the flower are swamped by the strength/ richness of the background.Just my personal taste, off course, i think I might have either gone for black or very pastel tones behind the flower.

I agree about the background, it’s obviously not as good as it could be. I used a new piece of software that I put on this morning and I rushed the job. That’s another lesson learned but that is the beauty of this site.
RJ.

rockfish 11 1

27 Mar 2010 5:18PM

Like 0

Glad to be of help earlier - I do like this image - but agree to some extent about the background. You're right, learning new things is what's great about the site. I'm still a begginer with Photoshop, but have alread learned a lot in couple of months.
Peter

Roly 14

27 Mar 2010 7:21PM

Like 0

Definatelt the "A" version for me.

rpba18205 Plus

11 1 4

27 Mar 2010 7:31PM

Like 0

Now uploaded a new version with black background. I tried different pastels but just couldn’t make it work. I think the black is better.
RJ.

metro074 11 8

27 Mar 2010 8:28PM

Like 0

Excellent RJ. Like the blue bg but they are all beautifuly presented. Well done
Carol

patspeirs 14

27 Mar 2010 9:03PM

Like 0

V2 seems a better balanced rendering - well presented.
Pat

xwang 12 56 8

27 Mar 2010 10:43PM

Like 0

Beautiful set,prefer V2.

bromley-smith 17 4

27 Mar 2010 10:44PM

Like 0

A lot of fabulous work considering V3. Love V2 with the black background.
Tony

michaelo Plus

15 15 1

28 Mar 2010 2:24AM

Like 0

excellent image,no 1 for me!

GlenD 14

28 Mar 2010 2:51AM

Like 0

Nicely worked shot
Glen

Ray42 13 3

28 Mar 2010 8:20AM

Like 0

Good ps work - certainly makes a good difference to the shot

Adderwatcher 12 60 19

28 Mar 2010 9:05AM

Like 0

V2 for me, excellent work!
Scott

essexdean 12 1

28 Mar 2010 9:49AM

Like 0

V2 for me, great shot

Techno Plus

13 6.1k 8

28 Mar 2010 9:57AM

Like 0

The important factor Rob is that the subject matter is right, and it is, the proficiency with the manipulation will come later, practice makes.................
Mal

Brian65 12 2

28 Mar 2010 10:38AM

Like 0

Wonderful image Rob, and well worked.
Brian

milky 18 5

28 Mar 2010 12:09PM

Like 0

Excellent shot well done-------Milky

Evgenya 11

28 Mar 2010 2:16PM

Like 0

Wonderful image Rob.
Evgenya

samarmishra 13 3

28 Mar 2010 3:47PM

Like 0

Sir, nice one.

NobbytheNobster 12 33 5

28 Mar 2010 11:29PM

Like 0

Excellent shot, superb detail and colour.
Ricky.

taggart Plus

17 47 14

29 Mar 2010 3:09AM

Like 0

You are correct, the black bg works the best of these!
A very fancy orchid!
Jennnnn

photophantom 13 108 3

29 Mar 2010 3:29AM

Like 0

such beautiful work RJ
Dennis

CherryMartin 13 10

29 Mar 2010 4:34AM

Like 0

beautiful, I really like it with the black background.

dmhuynh72 13 47 3

29 Mar 2010 11:02AM

Like 0

beautifully lit and excellent detail.

regards
Yung

Canadiann 11 2

29 Mar 2010 12:07PM

Like 0

Love that black bg. A beautiful flower and well presented. This is a great shot and I like the way you show the differences. Well done indeed.
Regards
Ann

colmar 14 42 35

29 Mar 2010 12:08PM

Like 0

Classic black and thats the one to make the beauty of this flower stand out so well Colin

WL_Harris 13 3 2

29 Mar 2010 12:41PM

Like 0

V2 with the black bg allows the flower to stand out very well.
Lee

Glyn1 12 4 1

29 Mar 2010 4:00PM

Like 0

V2 for me, I prefer the black bg.

Glyn

CaptainTweaky 12 14

29 Mar 2010 6:47PM

Like 0

Wonderful image of the flower but IMHO V1 & V2 look a little dismembered without the stem. I was thinking that perhaps V3 with the background blurred and darkened may have been quite effective. As there is orange in the flower the blurred grreen of the background may be complimentary - what do you think?
David

Last modified by CaptainTweaky on 29 Mar 2010 6:48PM

rpba18205 Plus

11 1 4

29 Mar 2010 7:21PM

Like 0

Quote:Wonderful image of the flower but IMHO V1 & V2 look a little dismembered without the stem. I was thinking that perhaps V3 with the background blurred and darkened may have been quite effective. As there is orange in the flower the blurred grreen of the background may be complimentary - what do you think?
David

You could be right. I will give it a try.
RJ.