Back Modifications (3)
Views: 107 (57 Unique)  Award Shortlist   


By Sharad

Tags: Digitally manipulated Landscape and travel

Take your photography to the next level and beyond...

  • NEWS

Why not join for free today?

Join for Free

Your total photography experience starts here

This photo is here for critique. Please only comment constructively and with suggestions on how to improve it.


jokinarnya 10 1 England
1 Feb 2011 11:20PM
Would look good on any wall. Great image.

Join ePHOTOzine for free and remove these adverts.

debu 8 India
1 Feb 2011 11:25PM
Super view,great capture.
Kdoone 8 2 United Kingdom
1 Feb 2011 11:31PM
Great Capture. Where is the location?
nik50 8 England
1 Feb 2011 11:34PM
Very Good!!
banehawi Plus
13 1.8k 3881 Canada
2 Feb 2011 1:33AM
Hi Sharad,

Im not Will Chung, but if he is the fantastic photographer I think he is I am flattered!

Back to this one.

Theres a few problems. One I noticed in the last is that you dont appear to be checking that your re sized shots for EPZ are sharp. After re sizing, - due to compression, some shots lose a lot of sharpness, and if this happens, just apply some more sharpening. I had to apply a substantial amount to this to make it look as I believe the original might have been. ( I am assuming the use of a tripod at 1.3 seconds of course)

Next is composition. The horizon is not on a third, and theres possibly too much width. You can certainly crop from the right to remove those black objects that seem to be intruding. Yoy can throw the horizon off a third when you are adding a frame, so keep an eye on it and adjust the frame as needed.

Then the horizon is very slightly off horizontal.

The script, - and perhaps you are new to it is also very close to the bottom, so you need a smaller font, or more border. When the type tool is selected, and the type layer is highlighted, you can drop down the font size and select a smaller one and the type changes on the fly.

I loaded a sharpened nod, with quite a bit more contrast and colour as the original appears soft and pastel, - the mod is more dramatic, and Ive cropped as I mentioned.

Hope you find this both helpful and constructive,

Best regards
DRicherby 9 269 725 United Kingdom
2 Feb 2011 1:06PM
This is a nice shot but, to me, it lacks balance because all the interest is on the right-hand side. There's nothing to make me want to look to the left. Since the two 'stepping stones' are pointing directly at the headland, a portrait orientation showing just the right-hand side would be more effective, I think.

Always check around the edge of the frame for things that are missing and things that shouldn't be there. You've shaved off the bottom of the nearest 'stepping stone' and there's a little black blob on the right-hand edge, at about the level of the second one. The latter probably can't be composed out but it's easily cloned.

Watch your focus, too. At 17mm and f/14, depth of field is essentially infinite. Focus on the nearest 'stepping stone' and everything should be perfectly sharp. Sharpening has helped in Willie's mod but the nearest parts of the stone are still a bit off.
Sharad 9 United Kingdom
2 Feb 2011 8:30PM
Thank you all for your constructive critique This has given me inspiration and made me look at things a different way,. I mod the shot in a portrait format but I am not sure which i like best. thanks again to all of you.
DRicherby 9 269 725 United Kingdom
2 Feb 2011 8:51PM
Portrait looks better to me. Wink By the way, in producing the mods, you've introduced a noticeable halo around the promontory. This may have come from sharpening with too high a radius. A radius of 0.8 is usually a good place to start for a photo like this which is sharp to begin with and just needs crisping up a bit. Either set the strength to 100 and adjust from there or do as Willie does and set it to the maximum and then reduce it until all the unwanted artifacts (such as haloes and harshness of fine textures) goes away. Whatever radius you use, avoid haloes and so on; smaller radii will let you use larger strength.

Sign In

You must be a member to leave a comment.

ePHOTOzine, the web's friendliest photography community.

Join For Free

Upload photos, chat with photographers, win prizes and much more.